Better Together: Outcomes of Cooperation Versus Competition in Social Exergaming

Abstract

Children and adolescents most often play active videogames, or exergames, in a social environment. Social play may enhance the potential benefits of an exergaming experience, much like group exercise and team sports are observed to improve physical activity-related outcomes above those of solitary exercise. Two ubiquitous elements of exergames are cooperation and competition. Previous literature suggests that cooperative and competitive aspects of exergames may affect physiological and psychosocial changes. Competitive play has been found to increase energy expenditure and aggression in short bouts of exergaming. Cooperative exergaming has been found to increase motivation, promote continued play, enhance self-efficacy, and increase pro-social behaviors. In one study, a cooperative exergaming condition also resulted in significant weight loss for overweight and obese adolescents. Individual player differences such as individual preferences, competitiveness, weight status, age, gender, and ethnicity may moderate effects. Although the current volume of literature on competition and cooperation in exergaming is small, social exergames hold promise as an engaging alternative to traditional physical activity interventions and may promote a broad range of positive outcomes for children and adolescents. Principles of cooperation and competition are applicable for developers of healthpromoting games. Future research is needed to further understand the mechanisms of how competition and cooperation in social exergaming impact physiological and psychosocial outcomes.

Competitive and cooperative arm rehabilitation games played by a patient and unimpaired person: effects on motivation and exercise intensity

“…This has an important implication for rehabilitation: participants who like competitive rehabilitation games will exercise significantly more intensely in such games . The finding is admittedly not surprising, as increased exercise intensity due to competition was already demonstrated in related fields such as weight loss [20]. Nonetheless, this is the first time that such increased exercise intensity was demonstrated in motor rehabilitation using impaired participants.…”

“…For example, potential benefits of competition may fade over multiple sessions as participants become used to the exercise and the novelty wears off. Alternatively, competition may increase aggression and frustration (as seen in competitive games for weight loss [20]), making participants unwilling to exercise again. These effects should be measurable over 3–4 sessions, allowing us to gauge “medium-term” effects of competitive exercises before launching a full clinical trial.…”

“…Competition and cooperation are known to be very motivating in games for entertainment [18, 19], but also have potential benefits for health. For example, cooperative games are known to increase motivation and energy expenditure in weight loss regimens [20]. …”

Investigating the Social and Temporal Aspects of Children's Physical Activity Games

“…Though not designed intentionally nor asked specifically, CtC was reported to be more gender neutral while GtG was assumed to be designed for girls. Children's preference to social interaction and effect on their physical activity was also confirmed by [7]. We anticipate that the detailed analysis of data will further help us understand the key elements that can effect children's engagement with these apps and the affect it had on their physical activity.…”

Data Mining in the Development of Mobile Health Apps: Assessing In-App Navigation Through Markov Chain Analysis (Preprint)

“…Han et al [18] define data mining as: '… the process of discovering interesting patterns and knowledge from large amounts of data. The data sources can include databases, data warehouses, raw log files, the Web and many more (p.8)'.…”