Benthic Community Responses to Water Removal in Tropical Mountain Streams

Abstract

Mountain streams that originally supported Hawaiian cultural practices have been diverted for development, agriculture and tourism for over 150 years. Habitat characteristics and benthic macroinvertebrate community responses to water withdrawal were studied in four West Maui Mountain watersheds. We compared riffle and cascade habitats upstream and downstream of the highest‐elevation diversion in each stream and further compared streams to understand variation among watersheds. Riffles were shallow areas with moderate flow, whereas cascades had high‐velocity water flowing over boulders and were separated into torrenticolous (submerged) and amphibious (splash zones on adjacent exposed rock) microhabitats. Among streams, downstream discharge was reduced by 84–99%, flow velocity was four times greater upstream, and depth was 50% lower downstream. There was a significant 44% reduction in downstream macroinvertebrate density (t = 3.261, df = 136, p = 0.0014); however, density did not significantly differ among streams (F = 1.95, df = 3, p = 0.125). Habitat‐corrected density, based on total available habitat area, indicated significantly greater proportions of native taxa in amphibious microhabitats compared with riffle and torrenticolous habitats. Non‐native Chironomidae and Trichoptera (Cheumatopsyche sp. and Hydroptila sp.) were dominant (>95%) and ubiquitous in riffles, whereas native Limonia sp. dominated (30%) amphibious microhabitats. Macroinvertebrate community structure varied among streams, sites and microhabitats, indicating inconsistent response to water withdrawal, dependent upon watershed size and microhabitat conditions. Our findings contribute to water management and restoration efforts focused on conservation of native species and habitat integrity in tropical streams worldwide. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Investigating the role of refuges and drift on the resilience of macroinvertebrate communities to drying conditions: An experiment in artificial streams

“…Indeed, global warming is producing a raise in temperature regimes, a reduction in ice cover and a shift in the spatial and seasonal amount of precipitations (Beniston, ; Middelkoop et al, ). Moreover, mountain lotic ecosystems are increasingly impacted by heavy flow regulation and water abstraction (Fenoglio, Bo, Cucco, & Malacarne, ; Gorbach, Shoda, Burky, & Benbow, ). Therefore, Alpine streams are changing from perennial to intermittent systems with possible but still largely unknown detrimental ecological effects (Leigh et al, ; Pinna et al, ).…”

Comparison of decapod communities across an urban-forest land use gradient in Puerto Rican streams

“…The alterations of the terrestrial environment as well the construction of barriers to migration change the local energy inputs as well the longitudinal connectivity among streams sections. These changes affect the organization and functions of the stream communities in the upper reaches of insular river drainages and are similar to effects initially outlined in the river continuum concept for larger watersheds (Vannote et al 1980;Tomanová et al 2008;Gorbach et al 2014).…”

Evaluating ecosystem effects of climate change on tropical island streams using high spatial and temporal resolution sampling regimes

“…In our study, we found that both abundance and biomass of invertebrates declined up to 20× and that caddisflies and midges were the dominant invertebrate taxa that drove these changes in biomass and abundance (Table S4). In comparison, two studies conducted on Maui Island, Hawaii, found a 44%–60% decline in invertebrate abundance and biomass as a result of flow reduction by river dams, but did not attribute the decline to certain taxa (Gorbach, Shoda, Burky, & Benbow, ; McIntosh, Schmitz, Benbow, & Burky, ). In addition, a congruent study along this rainfall gradient shows that the endemic shrimp, Atyoida bisulcata , has lower average biomass in streams with low baseflow (Tingley, ).…”

“…In comparison, two studies conducted on Maui Island, Hawaii, found a 44%-60% decline in invertebrate abundance and biomass as a result of flow reduction by river dams, but did not attribute the decline to certain taxa (Gorbach, Shoda, Burky, & Benbow, 2014;McIntosh, Schmitz, Benbow, & Burky, 2008). In addition, a congruent study along this rainfall gradient shows that the endemic shrimp, Atyoida bisulcata, has lower average biomass in streams with low baseflow (Tingley, 2017).…”