Benefits and drawbacks of communication visibility: from vicarious learning and supplemental work to knowledge reuse and overload

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to examine some of the benefits and drawbacks of communication visibility. Specifically, building on communication visibility theory, the authors study how and why message transparency and network translucence may increase knowledge reuse and perceived overload through behavioral responses of vicarious learning and technology-assisted supplemental work. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on survey data obtained from 1,127 employees of a global company operating in the industrial machinery sector, the authors used structural equation modeling to test the hypothesized model. Findings The results demonstrate that the two aspects of communication visibility yield somewhat differential benefits and drawbacks in terms of knowledge reuse and communication overload, through vicarious learning and supplemental work practices. Research limitations/implications The results demonstrate the relationship between different aspects of communication visibility and knowledge reuse, specifically through vicarious learning. Furthermore, the findings highlight a potential drawback of visibility – communication overload – specifically through technology-assisted supplemental work. Overall, network translucence seems more beneficial compared to message transparency in terms of knowledge reuse and communication overload. Originality/value The study connects with recent work on communication visibility by distinguishing differential direct and indirect effects of message transparency and network translucence. It also extends this work by testing relationships between communication visibility and a potential drawback of visibility – communication overload – specifically through technology-assisted supplemental work.

Using Enterprise Social Networks for Social Support in Virtual Teams

“…While the reduction of social support effort and barriers has various positive effects for work-related well-being, it has the obvious downside of producing frequent interactions and high volumes of information. In accordance with previous studies (e.g., van Zoonen et al, 2022a), our data suggest that some users experience this as overwhelming. These experiences play an important role in shaping usage norms that provide effective ways of organizing communication patterns such that users' exposure to irrelevant information is limited, and their ability to locate relevant information easily and quickly is enhanced.…”

Practical wisdom in the workplace: conceptualization, instrument development, and predictive power

“…Prior research attests to various benefits of external reflection for employees in an organizational context. It has been found that engaging in this practice fosters innovation (Abecassis-Moedas et al , 2016), boosts individual and team performance (Myers, 2018; Myers, 2021), promotes productive knowledge behavior (van Zoonen et al , 2022) and stimulates managerial learning (Bledow et al , 2017). Gibson (2008), Liew (2013) and Qayyum et al (2022) further argue that workers who engage in external reflection gain wisdom.…”

The Potential of Gamification for Social Sustainability: Meaning and Purposes in Agri-Food Industry

“…Indeed, by leveraging marketing strategies, businesses can promote the purchase of products, engaging more consumers and ensuring more market share through gamification processes and applications [15]. According to the marketing viewpoint, gamification is helpful in changing attitudes and behaviours fostering value creation for companies [16,17]. Indeed, it is able to use stimuli and gamified elements (such as rewards and badges) that are properly designed with the help of innovative technologies (e.g., virtual and augmented reality) to motivate consumers to follow rules As emerges from this analysis, the extant literature reviews on gamification are focused on systematising the theoretical foundation of gamification, consumer behaviours during the implementation of gamification strategies, impacts of gamification on learning, benefits from gamification adoption, the game design mechanism and features, the conceptualisation of gamification in the service field and related functions.…”