Behind the Rhodes statue: Black competency and the imperial academy

Abstract

Recent criticisms of the Rhodes Must Fall (RMF) Oxford campaign have problematized the presence of Black bodies within British higher education by reference to an ideal image of the impartial and discerning academy. In this article, I historically and intellectually contextualize the apprehension, expressed in the debates over RMF Oxford, that an intimate Black presence destabilizes the ethos of higher education. Specifically, I argue that much more than Rhodes’ statue implicates the British academy in the Empire’s southern African interests. I excavate a genealogy of academic debates regarding the effects of an increased proximity of Black presence to empire’s white spaces. These debates were initiated by social anthropologists in the interwar years primarily (albeit not solely) with regards to studies of southern Africa’s urbanizing spaces. What is more, such debates were highly influential to the study of ‘race relations’ in Britain’s postwar era of Commonwealth immigration. Critically, all these debates problematized the cognitive competency of African/Black peoples to inhabit white cultural spaces – including the academy – in ways that were not destabilizing of imperial order. Current campus campaigns such as RMF should not be evaluated against an ideal image of the academy. Rather, they form part of a continued confrontation with the afterlives of academic dispositions that were implicated in the imperial project that Rhodes was integral to.

Casting Stones with Intent: Transnational Interventions towards Ethical and Reparative Memorialisation

“…A case in point of such prior and long-standing debates over public memorialisation was the defacing of British imperialist and colonial politician Cecil Rhodes' statue at the campus of the University of Cape Town in 2015. This act of protest by student and activist Chumani Maxwele resonated globally and sparked the Rhodes Must Fall movement, which echoed in Britain with the demand of the removal of Cecil Rhodes statue from Oxford's Oriel College, as well as further calls to decolonise universities and their curriculum (Knudsen and Andersen 2019;Shilliam 2019). This initiative provoked fierce opposition, particularly in the right-wing media, based on the belief that the figure of Cecil Rhodes should be judged by the standards of his time, rather than by those of today.…”

Social Death and Rastafari Reason

“…Caught in between lives, this native, claimed Malinowski, would craft a reactionary politics, one which combined universalist relations a la associational mode with the ascriptive order of tribal life. These combinations led the "changing native" to ascribe to pathological ideologies, such as Black nationalism, which challenged the integrity of imperial order (Foks 2018;Shilliam 2019).…”

Is a Foundation Year Programme to an A-Level as a 7-UP is to a Sprite: Exploring an Attempt to Diversify an English University

“…These studies were part of a broader attempt by the University of Edinburgh's anthropologists "to gain theoretical understanding of the more obvious 'problems'; of race relations, including the integration of immigrant groups, racial prejudice and discrimination" (Little, 1960, p. 259). However, this focus had little lasting impact on British social anthropology (Mills, 2010;Shilliam, 2019).…”