Behavioral Theories and Motivational Features Underlying eHealth Interventions for Adolescent Antiretroviral Adherence: Systematic Review

Abstract

Background eHealth systems provide new opportunities for the delivery of antiretroviral therapy (ART) adherence interventions for adolescents. They may be more effective if grounded in health behavior theories and behavior change techniques (BCTs). Prior reviews have examined the effectiveness, feasibility, and acceptability of these eHealth systems. However, studies have not systematically explored the use of health behavior theories and BCTs in the design of these applications. Objective The purpose of this review was to explore whether health behavior theories and BCTs were considered to ground designs of eHealth systems supporting adolescents’ (10-24 years) ART adherence. More specifically, we examined which specific theories and BCTs were applied, and how these BCTs were implemented as design features. Additionally, we investigated the quality and effect of eHealth systems. Methods A systematic search was performed on IEEE Xplore, ACM, ScienceDirect, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases from 2000 to 2020. Theory use and BCTs were coded using the Theory Coding Scheme and the Behavior Change Technique Taxonomy version 1 (BCTTv1), respectively. Design features were identified using the lenses of motivational design for mobile health (mHealth). The number of BCTs and design features for each eHealth system and their prevalence across all systems were assessed. Results This review identified 16 eHealth systems aiming to support ART adherence among adolescents. System types include SMS text message reminders (n=6), phone call reminders (n=3), combined SMS text message and phone call reminders (n=1), electronic adherence monitoring devices (n=3), smartphone apps (n=1), smartphone serious games (n=1), gamified smartphone apps (n=1), leveraging existing social media (n=2), web-based applications (n=1), videoconferencing (n=1), and desktop applications (n=1). Nine were grounded in theory, of which 3 used theories extensively. The impact of adolescent developmental changes on ART adherence was not made explicit. A total of 42 different BCTs and 24 motivational design features were used across systems. Ten systems reported positive effects on 1 or more outcomes; however, of these ten systems, only 3 reported exclusively positive effects on all the outcomes they measured. As much as 6 out of 16 reported purely no effect in all the outcomes measured. Conclusions Basic applications (SMS text messaging and phone calls) were most frequent, although more advanced systems such as mobile apps and games are also emerging. This review indicated gaps in the use of theory and BCTs, and particularly the impact of developmental changes on ART adherence was not adequately considered. Together with adopting a developmental orientation, future eHealth systems should effectively leverage health theories and consider developing more advanced systems that open the door to using BCTs more comprehensively. Overall, the impact of eHealth systems on adolescent ART adherence and its mediators is promising, but conclusive evidence on effect still needs to be provided.

Developing a Tailored eHealth Self-Management Intervention for Patients With Chronic Kidney Disease in China: Intervention Mapping Approach

“…Previous studies recommend that a solid theoretical foundation is necessary to plan, design, evaluate, and implement eHealth self-management interventions [ 69 ]. However, our review found that only a few eHealth CKD self-management interventions reported the use of a specific theory [ 21 ], thereby limiting the understanding of mechanisms of action and hindering replication of eHealth intervention implementation.…”

MASI, a Smartphone App to Improve Treatment Adherence Among South African Adolescents and Young Adults With HIV: Protocol for a Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial

“…MASI includes multiple BCTs to address the various complex barriers to adherence experienced by adolescents and young adults. Other studies have found that interventions with more BCTs are more effective than those with a limited amount of BCTs [ 23 , 58 ]. The multiple BCTs are integrated into a variety of features within the MASI app that allows users to explore and use features that are most helpful and desirable to them.…”

“…Despite their promise, few digital health interventions to date have been developed and tested with adolescents and young adults in Eastern or Southern Africa. Among those that have been evaluated, basic applications such as SMS text messaging and phone calls have been the most common [ 23 ]. The findings of such SMS text messaging–delivered interventions have been mixed [ 24 ], highlighting the limitations of addressing only 1 adherence challenge (eg, forgetfulness), and underscoring the potential of incorporating multiple behavior change techniques (BCTs) to comprehensively address the varied adherence barriers experienced by adolescents and young adults.…”

Cost-Effectiveness of Anti-retroviral Adherence Interventions for People Living with HIV: A Systematic Review of Decision Analytical Models

“…To further implement, the respective settings need to consider the training of nurses and case managers that can influence and educate PLWHA [ 61 ]. For smartphone-based interventions, the availability of smartphones to PLWHA and their literacy level to use the smartphone applications are crucial before implementation [ 62 , 63 ]. A recent randomized-controlled trial (RCT) reported that smartphone-based adherence intervention was convenient to implement and easy to use for the overwhelming majority of participants, and PLWHA found the intervention useful and highly acceptable overall [ 62 ].…”