Before Kong Was King: Competing Methods in Hollywood Underscore

Abstract

In many histories of American film music, Max Steiner's score for King Kong (1933) marks a new era by establishing norms in original, symphonic underscoring that would dominate Hollywood for decades. Kong's reign, however, eclipses diverse approaches to underscoring practiced at studios before and after its release. In this study, I compare the methods of Max Steiner at RKO and Nathaniel Finston at Paramount to show how both influenced film music implementation and discourse in the years leading up to Kong. Steeped in the practices of silent cinema, Finston championed collaborative scoring and the use of preexistent music in films like Fighting Caravans (1931). Steiner preferred to compose alone and placed music strategically to delineate narrative space in films, as in Symphony of Six Million (1932), a technique he adapted for mediating exotic encounters in island adventure films preceding Kong. Although press accounts and production materials show that Steiner and Finston's methods proved resilient in subsequent years, Kong's canonic status has marginalized Finston's role and threatens to misdirect appraisals of Steiner's other work. Considering Finston's practices at Paramount alongside Steiner's pre-Kong scores at RKO illuminates the limitations of using only Kong as a model, and shows that Finston's perspective on film scoring in the early 1930s provides a corrective balance for understanding film musicians' work before and after Kong.

Screen Music and the Question of Originality

“…Recent scholarship primarily focusing on Hollywood's Golden Age, however, suggests the beginnings of an 'originality turn' in screen-music studies which opens up new and more subtle perspectives that are useful for this study (see for example Platte 2014). Peter Franklin has argued that classic Hollywood film music (primarily of the 1930s and 1940s) has often been perceived to lack the quality and rigor of late-Romantic music from which it is derived.…”