Bedside Teaching and the Acquisition of Practical Skills in Mid-Sixteenth-Century Padua

Abstract

Very little is known to this point about the practical skills which sixteenth-century physicians needed and applied at the bedside and even less about how these skills were taught to students. Drawing on student notebooks and on printed collections of consilia by Padua professors, this paper outlines the different settings in which case-centered and, more specifically, bedside teaching was imparted in mid-sixteenth-century Padua. It describes the range of diagnostic and therapeutic skills that students acquired thanks to this hands-on training at the patient's bedside, from uroscopy and feeling the pulse to the manual exploration of the patient's abdomen, which, historians have wrongly believed, physicians performed very rarely or not at all, and surgical skills. Taking a closer look, more specifically, at the role of teaching in the Hospital of San Francesco in Padua, the paper provides evidence that not only Giovanna Battista da Monte but also at least one other mid-sixteenth-century professor, Antonio Fracanzani, made systematic use of the teaching opportunities which the hospital offered. Ultimately, the paper will argue that clinical teaching in the hospital did not differ fundamentally from forms of bedside teaching in the patients' homes, however. Both became increasingly popular in Padua and elsewhere at the time, reflecting a growing appreciation for the practical and sensory skills which future physicians needed in addition to theoretical learning if they hoped to be successful in the highly contested early modern medical marketplace.

Educating physicians in seventeenth-century England

“…We easily assume that it was the academic prestige of their leading professors which made the top European universities so attractive, but student behavior at places like Padua and Paris suggests that what students valued most was access to clinical and anatomical experience (provided by hospitals and regular dissections), and the ancillary facilities provided by physic gardens, bookshops, and a penumbra of teaching and working opportunities with surgeons, apothecaries, and chemists (as Edinburgh was to exploit so successfully after 1726). These allowed students at these places to obtain the best of both worldsboth theory and practice, reason and experience, prestigious academic qualifications and direct induction to medical practice under the guidance of leading practitioners (Grell et al 2010, especially Klestinec 2010Stolberg 2014). The only city in England with a population, elite presence, hospital beds, and a supply of bodies which could support a body of medical practitioners capable of delivering this diverse range of experience was London, but the absence of a university had prevented this from happening.…”

Diagnosis and treatment of nervous system diseases at the beginning of the 19th century in Vilnius university clinics

“…Ðio dar bo ðal ti niai -lo ty nø kal ba pa rengtos Vil niaus im pera to rið ko jo uni ver si te to (1803-1832) me di ci nos ma gist rø di ser ta ci jos 1 . Ið 26 ner vø li gø klau si mus nag ri në ju siø diser ta ci jø ðia me dar be at rink tos pen kios, skir tos ner vø sis temos li goms: Jo ze fo Kor ne li jaus Raè kov sko di ser ta ci ja apie Ðv.…”

“…Ke li li go niai gy dy ti dël ner vø li gø: pa ra ly þiaus (2), gal vos skaus mo (2), epi lep si jos (1), en ce fa li to (1), apoplek si jos (1), Ðv. Vi to cho rë jos (1).…”

“…Nervø ligø diagnostika ir gydymas XIX a. pr. Vilniaus imperatoriðkojo universiteto klinikose1 Di ser ta ci jas ið lo ty nø kalbos ver të E. Sa ka laus kai të-Juo dei kie në.…”

Bedside Teaching in Neurology

“…Though popularized in modern medicine by Osler, the tradition of bedside teaching dates back to the late Middle Ages 1 and was later championed by Sylvius in the 17th century, who wrote:…”