Becoming familiar: how infrastructure engineers begin to use collaborative virtual reality in their interdisciplinary practice

Abstract

The design community has recently shown increased interest in using virtual reality (VR) in project review contexts. While single-user headsets currently attract most VR-related attention, room-like immersive VR environments can help facilitate design team engagement and shared exploration of projects. However, to date relatively little research concerns how large-scale VR environments are used in and adapted for professional practice. To address this gap, we set up a bespoke portable VR display system called 3D-MOVE in a major UK construction office to investigate how project team members used and evaluated collaborative VR processes. Over a three-month period, we conducted ten video-recorded VR sessions to observe how engineering professionals familiarize themselves with VR in order to help inform its deployment in practice. The study results show that emergent discussions about design models and questioning of design-related assumptions dominated all observed sessions, even though they were staged as technology demonstrations; which supports the social aspects of large-scale collaborative VR processes. However, before participants could focus on design review, they had to familiarize themselves with the VR technology and time required to do so varied depending on the complexity of the VR configuration. As the participants engaged with the VR environment, they reflected on their processes, requirements and expectations and provided feedback for improving the VR experience. Articulating this familiarization with collaborative VR can inform its deployment with respect to minimizing the learning curve and any distractions or discomfort associated with its use while maximizing the aspects of value-added collaborative engagement. Additional considerations concerning content, interactivity and logistics emerged as necessary to address before VR technologies can become standard practice.

Virtual reality as a tool to investigate and predict occupant behaviour in the real world: the example of wayfinding

“…Our results support the general assertion that although the experience of wayfinding in an immersive Virtual Environment is in many ways similar to an equivalent task in the same Real Environment, there are subtle differences. These include the mediation of technology (Nikolić et al 2019), the curated environment, the sense of embodiment (Kilteni et al 2012), and experiential novelty. The extent to which these differences affect the behaviours of participants in research such as this will depend on more work being done in a wider range of settings, with an explicit goal to correlate responses to nominally equivalent virtual and real environments.…”

Visualizing a New Sustainable World: Toward the Next Generation of Virtual Reality in the Built Environment

“…In this conceptual paper, we build on our prior research trajectory [3,13] and our review and synthesis of the wider literatures to characterize the role that virtual reality could play in visualizing and realizing preferred futures and addressing the grand challenges in our uncertain and changing world. We are sensitive to the difficulties of making preferred futures online, with its remoteness from associated places, people, and materials and vulnerability to excluding relevant experience [14].…”

Problems and Challenges in the Interactions of Design Teams of Construction Projects: A Bibliometric Study

“…The main methodology used for these purposes is agent-based modeling [50,51]. Alternatively, the design community has shown an increased interest in virtual reality in project review contexts, thus encouraging the use of collaborative virtual reality environments that facilitate design team participation and shared project exploration [52].…”