“…The direct synthesis reaction occurs on the surface of solid silicon particles, which is typical of heterogeneous catalytic reactions. The reaction rate and selectivity depend on chemical reactions such as the cleavage and formation of chemical bonds between the elements Si, Cu, C, Cl, and H, as well as physical processes such as MeCl adsorption, reaction product desorption, heat transport, charge transport, and diffusion processes. , In addition, they are also affected by the steadily changing surface compositions (silicon enrichment and depletion) and surface morphologies of the reactants and catalysts. , Furthermore, adding promoters such as zinc, stannum, or phosphorus further increases the complexity of direct synthesis by introducing new reaction pathways. This complexity is considered to be the main cause for the contradictory experimental results of this reaction and their controversial interpretations …”