Barriers to Treatment Engagement for Depression among Latinas

Abstract

In spite of successful treatment options for depression, the majority of Americans with severe depression do not receive treatment. Latinos are even less likely to engage in treatment than non-Hispanic Whites. The purpose of this study is to explore barriers to treatment engagement and, more specifically, how childhood adversity and gender-based violence (GBV) contribute to a lack of perceived support for treatment engagement. Experiences of GBV and childhood adversity can call into question deeply held family, cultural, and religious values, and affect the perceived quality of the therapeutic relationship and attitudes about depression treatment. A qualitative descriptive methodology was used to understand the experiences of a sample of 12 Latinas who were part of a diabetes prevention study (n = 67) and had been referred for treatment because of elevated symptoms of depression. Results indicate that the often-cited barriers to mental health care (i.e., language barriers, economic considerations, and lack of illness recognition) did not serve as deterrents for Latinas in this study. Participants recognized that they were depressed and agreed with the assessment of depression. However, none of the women followed up on the recommendation to seek care. What has emerged from this study is how cultural values, such as familismo and marianismo, and the lack of responsiveness from family and religious leaders in the context of exposure to GBV and childhood adversity created significant barriers to treatment engagement. This study highlights the need for nurses to screen for these exposures and to engage in shared decision making about treatment.

The efficacy of a behavioral activation intervention among depressed US Latinos with limited English language proficiency: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

“…This finding is consistent with a valued belief among Latinos of doing one’s part in one’s recovery (“poner de su parte”) rather than relying on medication which is viewed as more passive [15,20,21]. The concept of poner de su parte is especially consistent with the framework of behavioral psychotherapies [22].…”

COVID-19: The effects of job insecurity on the job engagement and turnover intent of deluxe hotel employees and the moderating role of generational characteristics

“…Job engagement can be defined as a positive and fulfilling state that is characterized by the vigor, and absorption of employees ( Schaufeli et al, 2002 ). In general, high job engagement means having a positive mental state on the job, and employees with high job engagement can be a particularly important variable in performance, because they improve organizational effectiveness, create more productive work environments, and reduce employee turnover ( Caplan and Whittemore, 2013 ).…”

Reflections of Low-Income, Second-Generation Latinas About Experiences in Depression Therapy

“…Their engagement strengthened when they realized the structure of the program was flexible and would work for their busy lives. However, Caplan and Whittemore (2013) found that Latinas with a past history of gender based violence or adversity in childhood may experience a diminishing ability to engage in depression treatment if their family does not support their quest to get treatment or if cultural values require women to hide problems to protect the reputation of the family. Furthermore, if gendered expectations call for Latinas who are mothers to endure emotional difficulties and remain silent, they may put off treatment.…”