Barriers and facilitators to implementation of direct fruit and vegetables provision interventions in kindergartens and schools: a qualitative systematic review applying the consolidated framework for implementation research (CFIR)

Abstract

Background Although children’s intake of fruit and vegetables has seen a recent rise, almost half of adolescents do not eat even one piece of fruit or vegetables per day. One way to address this problem is through interventions that provide fruit and vegetables directly to children in kindergartens and schools. For such interventions to meet their intended goals, what is important to consider in addition to impact is implementation. Our objective is to systematically review qualitative results reporting on the determinants (barriers and facilitators) to implementation of interventions that entail direct provision of fruit and vegetables in kindergarten and school settings and conduct a framework analysis of those results using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Methods A systematic search was designed and run in November 2019 for: MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase (Ovid), PsychINFO (Ovid), ERIC (Ovid), Cochrane Library Reviews and Cochrane Library Trials. A keyword search of the journal Implementation Science was completed. Screening of titles and abstracts (n = 5427) and full texts (n = 227), led to 14 included articles. Coding and analysis were done using the framework method and CFIR. Results The following CFIR constructs were found relevant: 1) intervention characteristics domain: ‘design quality and packaging’, ‘adaptability’ ‘cost’; 2) outer setting: ‘cosmopolitanism’, ‘external policy and incentives’ ‘patients’ needs and resources’; 3) inner setting: ‘implementation climate’, ‘readiness for implementation’ and ‘structural characteristics’; 4) characteristics of individuals: ‘individual stage of change’, ‘knowledge and beliefs about the intervention’ 5) process: ‘engaging’, ‘executing’ and ‘reflecting and evaluating’. The review stresses the dual role of parents as both supporting the implementation and targets of the intervention, which could have implications for the design and implementation of future fruit and vegetables interventions. Positive child perceptions of the value of the intervention and perceived behavior change due to the intervention were reported as relevant facilitators to implementation across several studies, and should be taken into consideration in future design efforts. Conclusions CFIR offers a systematic way to identify and organize barriers and facilitators to implementation of interventions in the kindergarten and school setting. Revisions are encouraged to allow adequate space for perceptions of various implementation actors and the target group. PROSPERO registration CRD42020167697.

Perceived benefits and challenges of school feeding programs in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: A qualitative study

“…This result is consistent with a review (32) of qualitative studies that were carried out in Niger (33), and Nigeria which which looked at how SFP was considered to affect students’ enrollment, completion, and academic success (34). Therefore, strengthening the SFP could be a crucial intervention to enhance students’ academic performance and improve the quality of their education.…”

Effects of the DAGIS randomized controlled trial on home environment and children’s food consumption according to the degree of implementation

“…All in all, as improving DOI is essential for gaining more intervention effects, particular effort should be put into involving and motivating parents in interventions that require parental actions. Methods to improve parental DOI may include increasing parental motivation, improving the easiness of implementation, and support [52][53][54].…”

Dietary behaviour and physical activity policies in Europe: learnings from the Policy Evaluation Network (PEN)

“…We conducted a systematic qualitative review of 14 studies reporting on the barriers and facilitators to implementation of interventions that entail the action of direct provision of fruit and vegetables in kindergarten and school settings. 76 The CFIR was used and the following determinants in the implementation of fruit and vegetables interventions in schools were identified: (i) intervention characteristics domain: ‘design quality and packaging’, ‘adaptability’ and ‘cost’; (ii) outer setting: ‘cosmopolitanism’, external policy and incentives’ and ‘patients’ needs and resources’; (iii) inner setting: ‘implementation climate’, ‘readiness for implementation’ and ‘structural characteristics’; (iv) characteristics of individuals: ‘individual stage of change’, ‘knowledge and beliefs about the intervention’ and finally of (v) process: ‘engaging’, ‘executing’ and ‘reflecting and evaluating’. The review stresses the dual role of parents as both supporting the implementation and targets of the intervention.…”