Barriers and challenges affecting the contemporary church's engagement in health promotion

Abstract

Issue addressed Christian churches have historically undertaken welfare and community service activities to practise faith and increase their relevance to communities. However, the church in Australia has received little attention from health promotion practitioners and researchers. The objective of this qualitative study was to explore the barriers and challenges that affect church engagement in health promotion to assist practitioners' understanding of the potential for these civil society organisations to play a role in health promotion programs and partnerships. Methods The research was based on interviews with five directors of church-affiliated organisations and with the church leaders (ministers, pastors, priests) of 30 churches in urban and rural Victoria. Analysis was iterative using open, axial and thematic coding. Results The challenges to church involvement in health promotion, as articulated by church leaders, fell under the themes of the social context of churches and the attributes of congregations. Major issues raised were perceived relevance, mistrust, contested agendas, discordant values within congregations, and risk management. Conclusion Although churches may take a different stance to health promotion agencies on a range of social and health issues, many have experience addressing social disadvantage and are prepared to commit resources to meet the needs of people outside their congregations. However, several factors inhibit the engagement of churches in health promotion including perceived irrelevance and community mistrust, agendas of conversion and values that conflict with health promotion. So what? Churches have a history of addressing social determinants of health such as housing, employment and food security. Deeper understanding of the challenges and barriers church leaders experience in undertaking health promotion work will facilitate more realistic and effective engagement by practitioners with these organisations.

The Role of Religious Behavior in Health Self-Management: A Community-Based Participatory Research Study

“…Research suggests that faith-based organizations (FBOs) can promote health and well-being both within congregations Caldwell and throughout communities (Ayton et al 2017). However, faith communities and their leaders, because of their localized context, do not often seek a research-and data-based approach to understanding the needs of their communities.…”

A Systematic Review of the Effectiveness of Brief Health Behaviour Change Interventions on Service Users Accessing the Third and Social Economy Sector

“…Te results of this review also established faith-based organisations and groups as a potential setting and workforce to deliver brief interventions. Tese settings may appear to lend themselves well to ofering health interventions due to an evident commitment to social justice [161] and regular interactions between religious members [162]; however, conficting values and a lack of public trust are among multiple barriers to implementation [161]. Both included church-based studies with African-American participants found contrasting results.…”

A University-Church-Community Look at Community Health Using Community-Based-Participatory Research

“…Few organizations have the cadence of influence to their congregants/adherents as much as the local church. Due to the prevalent nature of their contact, influence, and direction, churches can speak into the lives of those attending regarding all types of values, including health (Ayton et al 2016). A local church that has the health of its congregants as a priority can speak into the open and opening values systems within the congregation.…”