Bank competition and SMEs access to finance in India: evidence from World Bank Enterprise Survey

Abstract

PurposeThe primary purpose of this study is to investigate the effects of bank competition on SMEs' access to finance in selected Indian states. Using 9,281 firm-level observations from World Bank Enterprises Survey (WBES), this study tests the market power hypothesis versus the information hypothesis to determine whether bank competition promotes access to finance for financially constrained firms.Design/methodology/approachThe authors measure state-level bank competition using two structural indicators: the Herfindahl Hirschman Index (HHI) and three bank concentration ratios (CR3). The authors apply simple probit regression, probit model with sample selection (PSS) and two-stage least squares (2SLS) to examine the effects of bank competition on firms' financing constraints.FindingsThe results obtained through PSS and 2SLS indicate that bank competition alleviates firm's financing constraints and positively impacts its need for a bank loan and the decision to apply for bank credit. However, the prevalence of bank competition in promoting access to finance is more pronounced for small and medium-sized firms than for large firms. Higher bank competition also alleviates the credit constraints faced by female entrepreneurs.Practical implicationsReserve Bank of India (RBI) and other government stakeholders should ensure bank competition without hampering the agenda of bank consolidation to facilitate access to credit for SMEs. Regulators should also identify and monitor the financial institutions that make an insignificant contribution to promoting competitiveness in the financial system.Originality/valuePrevious studies primarily investigate the effect of bank competition on a firm's access to finance from advanced and cross-country perspectives. This study contributes to the literature on bank competition by examining its role in promoting access to finance from an emerging economy standpoint. Measurement of bank competition indicators at the state level is an additional contribution.

The Effect of Organizational Culture, Job Satisfaction on Entrepreneurship and Innovativeness in SMEs in Bogor City

“…This calls for originality in coming up with concepts, meticulous market analysis, and the capacity to create goods and services that not only satisfy but also surpass the demands and expectations of customers [9], [10]. In times of fierce rivalry, this becomes even more crucial because these qualities distinguish prosperous businesspeople from the competitors, enabling them to provide distinctive value and take the lead in the market [11], [12].…”