A rare complication of balloon dilation in the catheterization laboratory is the inability to deflate the balloon catheter. In the literature, methods described for deflating the balloon all involve puncture or rupture of the balloon while it is within the patient. Here we present a case in which a novel approach was used in order to puncture and deflate the balloon outside of the patient. We further looked at how balloons rupture when overinflated and the potential risks associated with doing this inside of a patient.