Balancing money and mission in a local church budget

Abstract

Purpose. This study of budgeting practices and attitudes to budgeting in a local church uses framework to consider the potential conflict between the "sacred" agenda of the church and the "secular" nature of accounting. Design/methodology/approach. Over a six month period, the author conducted a series of semi-structured interviews with key church leaders, and studied financial reports and the minutes of church meetings. Findings. Clergy and lay people alike, far from viewing accounting as an unwelcome intrusion into their church's sacred agenda, integrated belief in their church's mission with the need to raise and manage the money necessary to mobilise that mission. Research limitations/implications.Religion and religious organizations occupy a greater importance in society than academic accounting research would indicate, and this paper represents a response to that academic blind spot. Opportunities abound for further studies of the contribution accounting makes to other religious organizations, and to non-profit organizations whose goals are not primarily wealth creation. Practical implications. All organizations, even those with a sacred agenda, need to confront the reality of money and accounting if they are to achieve success. If they are unable to obtain or account for the resources they need for their mission, their ability to fulfil that mission is likely to be compromised. Originality/value. By portraying accounting as an enabling and liberating contributor to a church's fulfilment of its spiritual mission, this study demonstrates that attitudes to accounting are inextricably intertwined with religious beliefs, and that accounting can be a valuable tool in a cooperative attempt to implement a spiritual vision.

Financial Disclosure and Budgetary Practices of Religious Organization: A Study of Qaryah Mosques in Kuala Terengganu

“…We also found a large number of volunteers in our study. Similar findings were evident in studies by Duncan et al (1999), Wooten et al (2003), Bowrin (2004) and Irvine (2005). This is because nonprofit organizations tend to be heavily dependent on volunteers.…”

“…Accountants may give advice but they should not be put in control. Irvine (2005) also found that the need for accounting to achieve the sacred mission of the church organization is pertinent. Thus, the resistance to accounting, in principle, is minimal.…”

A Case Study of Internal Control Practices in Islamic Non-Profit Organisations in Malaysia

“…This practice is also suggested to be practiced by CLBG A and CLBG C as it will increase the accurate management of Islamic charity funds based on the donors' preference. By having good practice in documentation and records, it will lead to more reliability, especially for audit process and give more assurance for financial disclosure (Irvine 2005;Shiri et al 2012;Spitzer 2005).…”

“…This is due to the set up requirement by the CCM for every company including CLBG type to submit audited financial statements annually to them. By having the audit process, it is also required for these three CLBGs to have an adequate and reliable financial documentation and records (Irvine 2005;Shiri et al 2012;Spitzer 2005). Thus, this shows that all three CLBGs comply with the independent checks on the performance element for control activities.…”

Memaknai Sisi Akuntansi Sumbangan Keagamaan Masyarakat Hindu Bali

“…Walaupun tidak lazim, penelitian praktik akuntansi pada lembaga keagamaan se perti gereja banyak dilakukan oleh beberapa peneliti akuntansi. Salah satu peneliti (Irvine 2005) menyimpulkan bahwa pendeta dan orang awam percaya akuntansi tidak mengganggu agenda suci yang dikerjakan oleh gereja. Sebaliknya, akuntansi merupakan bagian penting yang terintegrasi dengan kepentingan gereja demi mencapai misi kudus karena temuan ini berkepentingan dengan masyarakat sebagai sumber keuangannya dalam bentuk sumbangan, sedekah atau bentuk bantuan sosial lainnya yang berasal dari masyarakat (publik).…”