Bacteriophages are deemed either lytic (virulent) or temperate, respectively depending on whether their genomes are transmitted solely horizontally, or both horizontally and vertically. To elucidate the ecological and evolutionary conditions under which natural selection will favor the evolution and maintenance of lytic or temperate modes of phage replication and transmission, we use a comprehensive mathematical model of the dynamics of temperate and virulent phage in populations of bacteria sensitive and resistant to these viruses. For our numerical analysis of the properties of this model, we use parameters estimated with the temperate bacteriophage Lambda, l, it's clear and virulent mutants, and E. coli sensitive and resistant -refractory to these phages. Using batch and serial transfer population dynamic and reconstruction experiments, we test the hypotheses generated from this theoretical analysis. Based on the results of this jointly theoretical and experimental study, we postulate the conditions under which natural selection will favor the evolution and maintenance of lytic and temperate modes of phage replication and transmission. A compelling and novel prediction this in silico, in vitro, and in plastico study makes is lysogenic bacteria from natural populations will be resistant-refractory to the phage for which they are lysogenic as well as lytic phage sharing the same receptors as these temperate viruses.