Methylation of the enolates 7, 24, 28 and 33 and protonation of the enolates 10, 27, 31 and 36 are diastereoselective in conformity to a general rule, summarised in the drawing 1, governing the stereochemistry of electrophilic attack on a double bond adjacent to a stereogenic centre. The sense of the selectivity is, with one exception, opposite to that of the corresponding nucleophilic attack on a carbonyl group adjacent to a stereogenic centre, which, with the same exception, follows Cram's and the Felkin-Anh rule, summarised in the drawing 2. The exception is probably the reduction 40+ 38 + 39, with 39 as the major product. This result is inconsistent with Cram's and the Felkin-Anh rule if the isopropyl group is counted as 'larger' than the phenyl group, whereas the Grignard reaction 37-38 + 39, where 39 is again the major product, and the corresponding electrophilic reactions 33 -34 + 35, with 34 as the major product, and 36 + 34 + 35, with 35 as the major product, are all consistent with isopropyl being effectively larger than phenyl.For some years we have been studying the diastereoselectivity of electrophilic attack on a C=C double bond adjacent to a stereogenic centre in the general sense 1. Our interest in thistype of diastereoselectivity stems from our discovery, in several types of open-chain structure, of high levels of selectivity, with many applications in organic synthesis, when the large group, L, is a silyl group, and the small group, S, is hydrogen. Our interest was further stimulated by the realisation that this type of diastereoselectivity, even without a silyl group being present, was much less well studied, in spite of its fundamental nature, than the corresponding nucleophilic attack on trigonal carbon-the reaction of nucleophiles with carbonyl groups having an adjacent stereogenic centre, first systematised by Cram 30 years before we began our work, and explained with a transition structure 2, with successive refinements by Karbatsos,' Felkin,3 and Anh and their c o -~o r k e r s . ~ We present, in this and the following eight papers, all of our work to date in this area, with the exception of that which has already appeared in full,5 and that which relates to natural product synthesis, which will follow in a second series of papers. To set the scene, we discuss here the steric factors that are either known or expected to affect the diastereoselectivity, and we also report our experiments on a simple enolate system with only carbon groups on the stereogenic centre, designed to provide a paradigm for this type of selectivity, and reported already in preliminary form.6At the end of the present series we append a tenth paper summarising our results and conclusions. Less dedicated readers might like to turn to that paper now. t
Results and DiscussionElectrophilic Attack on Trigonal Carbon Adjacent to a Stereogenic Centre.-Early work in this area7 was largely t I. Fleming, J. Chem. SOC.,