Automatic, wearable-based, in-field eating detection approaches for public health research: a scoping review

Abstract

Dietary intake, eating behaviors, and context are important in chronic disease development, yet our ability to accurately assess these in research settings can be limited by biased traditional self-reporting tools. Objective measurement tools, specifically, wearable sensors, present the opportunity to minimize the major limitations of self-reported eating measures by generating supplementary sensor data that can improve the validity of self-report data in naturalistic settings. This scoping review summarizes the current use of wearable devices/sensors that automatically detect eating-related activity in naturalistic research settings. Five databases were searched in December 2019, and 618 records were retrieved from the literature search. This scoping review included N = 40 studies (from 33 articles) that reported on one or more wearable sensors used to automatically detect eating activity in the field. The majority of studies (N = 26, 65%) used multi-sensor systems (incorporating > 1 wearable sensors), and accelerometers were the most commonly utilized sensor (N = 25, 62.5%). All studies (N = 40, 100.0%) used either self-report or objective ground-truth methods to validate the inferred eating activity detected by the sensor(s). The most frequently reported evaluation metrics were Accuracy (N = 12) and F1-score (N = 10). This scoping review highlights the current state of wearable sensors' ability to improve upon traditional eating assessment methods by passively detecting eating activity in naturalistic settings, over long periods of time, and with minimal user interaction. A key challenge in this field, wide variation in eating outcome measures and evaluation metrics, demonstrates the need for the development of a standardized form of comparability among sensors/multi-sensor systems and multidisciplinary collaboration.npj Digital Medicine (2020) 3:38 ; https://doi.

A wearable heart rate measurement device for children with autism spectrum disorder

“…In recent years, wearable devices have played a crucial role in many different applications, including occupational accident prevention, fitness, and medical care, thanks to the ability to combine many low-cost sensors in the same network 4 – 6 . In the healthcare field, user-friendly wearable devices allow vital signs to be measured and monitored with different granularity levels.…”

A Real-Time Eating Detection System for Capturing Eating Moments and Triggering Ecological Momentary Assessments to Obtain Further Context: System Development and Validation Study

“…In a recent literature survey, Bell et al reported that 33 research studies performed an in-field assessment with a meal detection system [ 14 ]. The in-field assessment entailed participants using the sensor setup in a “free-living” condition.…”

“…For example, identifying when individuals eat can be used to infer if individuals are consuming food at regular intervals of time. Recent ubiquitous computing research has shown promise in eating detection, primarily showing various ways to infer when an individual is eating [ 10 - 14 ]. However, dietary patterns of an individual are not exclusively related to their interactions with food.…”

Underreporting of Dietary Intake: Key Issues for Weight Management Clinicians

“…They are only beginning to be deployed in non-laboratory settings that capture natural behaviors, and developers have been faced with technological challenges and behavioral confounders, such as the hand-tomouth activity involved in smoking or nail biting. Bell and colleagues recently (March 2020) published a review of 33 peer-reviewed journal or conference papers published through December 2019, describing 40 studies that focused on current use of wearable devices and sensors that automatically detect eating activity in free-living research settings [46]. They note that measures for evaluating performance of these devices in the field are highly varied and lack uniformity.…”