Attitudes of primary care physicians towards patients with mental illness in Hong Kong

Abstract

Introduction: This study aims to describe the attitudes of primary care physicians towards mental health patients in Hong Kong, especially to examine the doctors' views on schizophrenia and depression, and the influence of their demographic variables. Methods: A questionnaire developed by the research team was sent to members of Hong Kong College of Family Physicians. Potential respondents were allocated on equal basis to one of the two sets of questionnaire, set 1 for clinical vignette of schizophrenia and set 2 for depression. Results: A response rate of 37% (500 of 1,360) was achieved. There were 255 and 245 returned questionnaires for set 1 and set 2, respectively. Comparing the two clinical vignettes, there were large differences in their willingness to have the patient on practice list for mental issues (40.0% for schizophrenia versus 71.5% for depression) and to deal with the patient's needs (37.0% versus 60.9%). Multiple ordinal logistic regression analysis showed that doctors with the following demographic factors tended to have more worries or stigma on mental health patients: "having longer years of practice," "being female," "working in hospital," "employed in public sector," and "not having a relative/friend with mental health problems." Discussion: Our study shows that two-thirds of primary care doctors are prepared to look after patients with depression, which is substantially higher than that for schizophrenia. In contrast with the Australian findings, the experienced doctors in Hong Kong have more negative attitudes towards mental health patients than the younger ones.

Attitudes towards mental illness among medical students in China: Impact of medical education on stigma

“…Stigma in Chinese society should be understood within the context of the Chinese culture, philosophy, and history. In Chinese society, not only the involved individual but also their families have traditionally been held responsible for mental disorders and aberrant behavior (Feldman & Crandall, ; Lam, Lam, Lam, & Ku, ). Accordingly, mental disorders in one's family have been a highly guarded secret in the interest of maintaining the prestige of both the individual and the family.…”

The chasm of care: Where does the mental health nursing responsibility lie for the physical health care of people with severe mental illness?

“…Similarly, Happell et al () highlighted the lack of importance that mental health nurses placed on health promotion as it was deemed that the person would not adhere to these intervention programmes. Stigma directed toward people with a mental illness is an important component of therapeutic fatalism (Lam et al ; Nash ), and health professionals demonstrate the same rate of stigmatizing behaviours towards this client group as the general population (Chadwick et al ; Nash ). However, as many people with a severe mental illness lack assertiveness and confidence health professionals' stigmatising attitudes and behaviours only serve to increase the person's vulnerability to the development of physical co‐morbidities and to decrease their willingness to access services (Chadwick et al ).…”

A structured review of psychiatric rehabilitation for individuals living with severe mental illness within three regions of the Asia‐Pacific: Implications for practice and policy

“…Stigma is burdensome, affecting people living with SMI and their family members and hindering both recovery and rehabilitation (Koschorke et al, ; Lam, Lam, Lam, & Ku, ; Ye et al, ). Negative societal attitudes and stigma are major obstacles to the improvement of quality of life for people living with SMI (Koschorke et al, ; Lam et al, ).…”