Attitudes and practices of gynecologists in Jaipur toward management of menopause

Abstract

Background:In earlier days, hormone replacement therapy (HRT) was recommended for menopause symptoms and also gained much popularity. However, the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) studies suggested an increased risk of cardiovascular and Alzheimer's disease. These findings led to a dramatic decrease in hormone therapy (HT) prescriptions all over the world. However, the WHI conclusions remain debatable especially because of contradictory results from antecedent studies. Inspite of these controversies, post-WHI, most gynecologists refrain from prescribing MHT (menopausal hormone replacement therapy, MHT). Furthermore, many Indian gynecologists prefer to prescribe alternative treatments that would help alleviate symptoms and thus avoid HRT. We decided to carry out a survey and document the current opinions regarding indications of HRT and alternative therapies and prescribing practices of Jaipur-based gynecologists.Objective:This study was designed to find out the current attitudes and practices of gynecologists (Jaipur) towards management of menopause.Materials and Methods:A questionnaire concerning attitudes, management strategies, and use of HT was mailed out to gynecologists, and they are asked to complete the questionnaire. Data were analyzed using the total number of respondents (n = 321). The results were analyzed using a simple percentage method as this was most suitable for this kind of studies.Results:From the results, 69.04% gynecologists were currently prescribing MHT. Hot flashes were the most common indication for MHT prescriptions and 78.57% were familiar with controversies surrounding WHI study. Also, 61.9% would consider using MHT for themselves. Alternative therapy was adopted by 83.48% in their prescribing practice. The reason cited by 71% for preferring alternative therapies was that it was safer and less controversial.Conclusions:The prescribing practices of Jaipur gynecologists in lieu of ongoing controversies surrounding HT have shifted and now also support alternative therapies for menopause management. In this era of phasic prescriptions, for immediate relief of hot flashes and mood swings, MHT was favored. However, for long-term management of women with poor compliance, alternative therapies were considered a safer option.

Study of menopausal symptoms, and perceptions about menopause among women at a rural community in Kerala

“…There was a great disparity in their minds too whether to prescribe HRT or not. [ 9 ] There is a huge debate over the interpretation of the findings of the Women's health initiative study. It was stated in 2007 that age is one of the major factors in prescription of HRT.…”

Breast Cancer Awareness among Middle Class Urban Women - a Community-Based Study from Mumbai, India

“…We conducted this exploratory study to assess the breast cancer awareness in our community as a first step towards designing the awareness-based breast cancer early detection program. We chose postal survey to collect the data, as interview-based surveys are more expensive (Cummings et al, 2001;Gibson et al, 1999) surveys are not common in India (Gupta et al, 2011) and most of them aim to gather information from the physicians or medical students and use multiple methods for data collection (Gupta et al, 2007;Meherishi et al, 2010). Community-based cancer-related health surveys are scarce and most of the literature available regarding cancer surveys have included personal interviews, but not self-reported information (Mayur et al, 2013;Rao et al, 2005;Mahendra et al, 2014;Garg et al, 2010).…”

Soybeans: A Boon for Menopausal Women

“…Witnessing the utility of isoflavones in the clinical treatment of menopausal problems such as hot flushes and vaginal dryness, the balance for soy consumption and its products has changed. 11 The US Department of Agriculture estimates that 100 g of cooked green soybeans without salt consists of:…”