In the experimental-theoretical study of Ag on Pt(111), we use experimental He scattering data from low-coverage (single adsorbate) systems to determine an empirical He/Ag-Pt potential of good quality. Then, we carry out He scattering calculations for high coverage and compare with experiments for these systems. The conclusion is that the actual experimental phase corresponds to small compact Ag clusters of narrow size distribution, with partial translational disorder.2