“…However, the analysis of UUPQ presented in [13] and [14] was incomplete and not quite correct from the following reasons: in [13] the overload distortion was neglected and the optimization of r max was not done (instead of that, the value of r max for the scalar uniform quantizer was used); in [14] the expression for the overload distortion was not given and the method for calculation of r max was not explained. Due to these reasons, performances of UUPQ calculated using the analysis from [13], [14] is not accurate enough.…”