Association of rule of law and health outcomes: an ecological study

Abstract

ObjectivesTo explore whether the rule of law is a foundational determinant of health that underlies other socioeconomic, political and cultural factors that have been associated with health outcomes.SettingGlobal project.ParticipantsData set of 96 countries, comprising 91% of the global population.Primary and secondary outcome measuresThe following health indicators, infant mortality rate, maternal mortality rate, life expectancy, and cardiovascular disease and diabetes mortality rate, were included to explore their association with the rule of law. We used a novel Rule of Law Index, gathered from survey sources, in a cross-sectional and ecological design. The Index is based on eight subindices: (1) Constraints on Government Powers; (2) Absence of Corruption; (3) Order and Security; (4) Fundamental Rights; (5) Open Government; (6) Regulatory Enforcement, (7) Civil Justice; and (8) Criminal Justice.ResultsThe rule of law showed an independent association with infant mortality rate, maternal mortality rate, life expectancy, and cardiovascular disease and diabetes mortality rate, after adjusting for the countries’ level of per capita income, their expenditures in health, their level of political and civil freedom, their Gini measure of inequality and women's status (p<0.05). Rule of law remained significant in all the multivariate models, and the following adjustment for potential confounders remained robust for at least one or more of the health outcomes across all eight subindices of the rule of law. Findings show that the higher the country's level of adherence to the rule of law, the better the health of the population.ConclusionsIt is necessary to start considering the country's adherence to the rule of law as a foundational determinant of health. Health advocates should consider the improvement of rule of law as a tool to improve population health. Conversely, lack of progress in rule of law may constitute a structural barrier to health improvement.

The legal determinants of health: harnessing the power of law for global health and sustainable development

“…114 This formalises a longstanding understanding that the pursuit of justice is an essential ingredient of sustainable development. 115…”

Knowledge of HIV Status Is Associated With a Decrease in the Severity of Depressive Symptoms Among Female Sex Workers in Uganda and Zambia

“…With the growing recognition that rule of law is a powerful determinant of health and the inclusion of access to justice within the Sustainable Development Goals, there has been a significant increase in actions to prevent discrimination against key populations and people living with HIV (84,85). Some countries have introduced laws that explicitly protect people from discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation, gender identity or HIV status, both in health settings and more broadly (86).…”

Governance commitment to reduce maternal mortality. A political determinant beyond the wealth of the countries

“…Over the last decade, some studies have established a direct association between health outcomes (Ciccone et al, 2014; Ruger, 2006)—such as the reduction of mortality rates (Farag et al, 2012)—and specific dimensions of governance—which is understood as the way in which a society organises and manages its affairs collectively. In this sense, level of democracy was observed to be positively related to health (Krueger et al, 2015) and rule of law to child mortality (Lin et al, 2014), maternal mortality (Holmberg and Rothstein, 2011; Pinzon-Rondon et al, 2015; Sajedinejad et al, 2015) and other health issues (Klomp and de Haan, 2008; Lazarova and Mosca, 2008). Maternal mortality has also been found to be associated with the quality of government (Holmberg and Rothstein, 2011).…”