Association between dietitians' personality profiles and practice areas

Abstract

Aim: Personality traits refer to habitual patterns of behaviour, thoughts and emotions, and have been shown to influence health professionals' career pathways. The present study explored the associations between dietitians' personality profiles and the areas of dietetic practice they have previously worked. Methods: Survey of 346 dietitians; 95% female; aged 32 ± 10 years; median 7 years (range 0-35) since graduation. Personality traits were investigated using the Temperament and Character Inventory, and cluster analysis was used to group participants into three clusters, known as Profiles, based upon common combinations of personality trait levels. Relationships between personality clusters and areas of dietetic practice were investigated using univariate and multivariate analyses. Results: Compared with other participants, dietitians in Profile A displayed moderate levels of Harm Avoidance, Persistence and Self-Directedness; dietitians in Profile B displayed higher levels of Persistence and Self-Directedness, and lower levels of Harm Avoidance; and dietitians in Profile C displayed higher levels of Harm Avoidance and lower levels of Persistence and Self-Directedness. Dietitians in Profile A were twice as likely to have worked in Private Practice/Consultancy compared with Profile C (OR = 1.90, 95% CI: 1.07-3.38, P < 0.05), and dietitians in Profile B were over four times more likely to have worked in Food Service Management compared with Profile C (OR = 4.35, 95% CI: 1.47-12.84, P < 0.01). Conclusions: Dietitians' personality may influence their decision to work in some areas of dietetic practice. Employees and employers should be mindful of personal traits when making employment decisions because some environments may be more conducive to specific attributes of dietitians to facilitate competent performance in a role.

The tension between efficiency and effectiveness: a study of dietetic practice in primary care

“…Time spent face‐to‐face was privileged above time spent in other tasks, presumably because the face‐to‐face time was seen as engendering the outcomes. This is an interesting finding, especially given it is counter to the trend towards technology delivered services, although this is perhaps to be expected in a profession based on counselling . Effectiveness was a highly valued aspect of primary care, perhaps even more highly valued than efficiency, because it was seen as client‐focused, establishing a tension between these two important constructs.…”

Personalised Nutrition Technologies and Innovations: A Cross-National Survey of Registered Dietitians

“…The finding that those who practiced technology-enabled personalised nutrition perceived less risk of genetic testing was as expected. In comparison to the general population, dietitians have been found to have average levels of novelty-seeking behaviour and high levels of harm avoidance [46,47]. This implies that more could be done to encourage discussion on the risks of genetic testing in dietetics practice.…”

Personality profile of dietetics students from medical universities in the context of efficacy of prospective dietetic counseling – a Polish study

“…The European Federation of the Associations of Dietitians (EFAD) also stresses that an important educational goal in dietetics is ' If we thus assume that the patient-centred counseling approach is the basic value of dietetic practice that enhances the chances of behavioural change [3][4], then it is justifiable to ask about the personality of the dietitians that enables a desirable approach to be introduced. The state of knowledge on the personality characteristics of dietitians is negligible, based only on very few publications [8][9][10], of which only one concerns the personality correlates of pursuing the…”