Association between changes in harm perceptions and e-cigarette use among current tobacco smokers in England: a time series analysis

Abstract

Background: There is a decreasing trend in the proportion of individuals who perceive e-cigarettes to be less harmful than conventional cigarettes across the UK, Europe and the US. It is important to assess whether this may influence the use of e-cigarettes. We aimed to estimate, using a time series approach, whether changes in harm perceptions among current tobacco smokers have been associated with changes in the prevalence of e-cigarette use in England, with and without stratification by age, sex and social grade. Methods: Respondents were from the Smoking Toolkit Study, which involves monthly cross-sectional household surveys of individuals aged 16+ years in England. Data were aggregated monthly on~300 current tobacco smokers between 2014 and 2019. The outcome variable was the prevalence of e-cigarette use. The explanatory variable was the proportion of smokers who endorsed the belief that e-cigarettes are less harmful than combustible cigarettes. Covariates were cigarette (vs. non-cigarette combustible) current smoking prevalence, past-year quit attempt prevalence and national smoking mass media expenditure. Unadjusted and adjusted autoregressive integrated moving average with exogeneous variables (ARIMAX) models were fitted. Results: For every 1% decrease in the mean prevalence of current tobacco smokers who endorsed the belief that e-cigarettes are less harmful than combustible cigarettes, the mean prevalence of e-cigarette use decreased by 0.48% (β adj = 0.48, 95% CI = 0.25-0.71, p < .001). Marginal age and sex differences were observed, whereby significant associations were observed in older (but not in young) adults and in men (but not in women). No differences by social grade were detected. Conclusions: Between 2014 and 2019 in England, at the population level, monthly changes in the prevalence of accurate harm perceptions among current tobacco smokers were strongly associated with changes in e-cigarette use.

Prospective associations between nicotine beliefs and tobacco-related susceptibility, curiosity, and use in U.S. adults

“…Given that changes in nicotine beliefs tended to shift to greater harm over time in Class 3, the lack of associations at Wave 10 could be explained by Class 3 members looking more like Class 1 members at follow-up. These increases in tobacco-related harm perceptions over time are consistent with other studies in the U.S. (Elton-Marshall et al, 2020;Huang et al, 2019b;Strong et al, 2019) and England (Perski et al, 2020;Tattan-Birch et al, 2020).…”

Re-examining the Association Between E-Cigarette Use and Myocardial Infarction: A Cautionary Tale

“…It is doubtful that this reflects a reduction in e-cigarettes' riskiness. Given the public's growing skepticism toward e-cigarettes, 4,18 this may reflect the most at-risk smokers becoming less likely to switch to e-cigarettes. Some of such smokers quit using other means, whereas others continue to use combustible cigarettes.…”

COVID‐19, smoking, vaping and quitting: a representative population survey in England

“…In our sample, one in 10 current e‐cigarette users attempted to quit vaping due to concerns about COVID‐19. These attempts to quit vaping might stem from the deteriorating perceptions about the harms associated with e‐cigarette use among smokers in England [38,39].…”