Non-typhoidal Salmonella is a common cause of enteric disease in humans and can be transmitted through food and contact with live animals. In 2020, an outbreak of Salmonella Hadar illnesses was linked to contact with non-commercial, privately-owned (backyard) poultry including live chickens, turkeys, and ducks, resulting in 848 illnesses. From late 2020 into 2021, this Salmonella Hadar strain caused an outbreak that was linked to ground turkey consumption.Core genome multilocus sequence typing (cgMLST) analysis determined that the Salmonella Hadar isolates detected during the outbreak linked to backyard poultry and the outbreak linked to ground turkey were closely related genetically (within 0-16 alleles). Epidemiologic and traceback investigations were unable to determine how Salmonella Hadar detected in backyard poultry and ground turkey were linked, despite this genetic relatedness. Enhanced molecular characterization methods, such as analysis of the pangenome of Salmonella isolates, might be necessary to understand the relationship between these two outbreaks. Similarly, enhanced data collection during outbreak investigations and further research could potentially aid in determining if these transmission vehicles are truly linked by a common source and what reservoirs exist across the poultry industries that allow Salmonella Hadar to persist. Further work combining epidemiologic data collection, more detailed traceback information, and genomic analysis tools will be important in the future of monitoring and investigating enteric disease outbreaks.