Assessment of Musculoskeletal Disorder Risk with Hand and Syringe use in Chemotherapy Nurses and Pharmacy Assistants

Abstract

The purpose of this thesis was to examine hand actions required of nurses and pharmacy assistants involved with chemotherapy drug administration over a work shift, and propose associated risk control strategies. There is a need to evaluate and redesign manual "pushing" and mixing of chemotherapy drugs to prevent musculoskeletal disorders and associated healthcare costs. Muscle activity of the forearm flexor and extensor muscles, and thumb forces, were measured from 5 lab nurses, 5 floor nurses and 5 pharmacy assistants who had their actions recorded throughout their shift. Lab nurses performed an average of 1.85 ± 0.48 hand efforts per min, floor nurses performed 1.62 ± 0.09 per min, while pharmacy assistants performed 5.29 ± 1.27 per min. Syringe use accounted for 17% of the pharmacy assistants' shift and 12% each for the floor and lab nurses. The tasks of drawing fluid and manually pushing treatment represented 10% of the work day. The left forearm flexors generated the highest activity over the workday and across tasks while only resting for 6% of the workday. The high number of hand efforts, combined with prolonged durations, and lack of muscular rest show evidence of muscular overload over the course of the shift as well as illustrate that the pharmacy assistants are at higher risk for WMSD. The results may also help explain the documented injury statistics and complaints associated with the arm, hand and thumb and support the implementation of a chemotherapy robot to reduce the risk associated with tasks performed by the pharmacy assistants. Further, the findings of this thesis can act as a guide for future evaluation and research of workplaces with similar syringe and hand M.Sc. Thesis -Victoria MacDonald Master University -Kinesiology v demands. The risk reducing strategies presented may also be applied to other jobs where hand and syringe use is repetitive and prolonged.

Median nerve travel and deformation in the transverse carpal tunnel increases with chuck grip force and deviated wrist position

“…Participants performed the chuck grip in both a low force and a high force condition, set relative to their individual strength at 10% and 40% of their maximum voluntary effort (MVE). A chuck grip at low and high force levels was selected since this grip type is well documented within field-based studies in ergonomics (Gerhardsson & Hagberg, 2014;MacDonald & Keir, 2018). Also, previous studies have observed changes when chuck gripping forcefully (25% and 50% compared to 0% MVE) with the wrist in 30 • flexion (Cowley et al, 2017).…”

The Impact of Work Method on Musculoskeletal Disorders Complaints in Pharmacy Unit

“…In like manner, there was a significant association between non-ergonomic position and back pain. Excessive muscle work done by pharmacy workers related to the use of needle and other hand-related work combined with long working period/duration, thumb press force, high muscle work, and lack of rest causes MSDs to happen (39)(40)(41).…”

Ergonomics and Human Factors in Healthcare System Design – An Introduction to This Special Issue

“…(1) tools and technologies (Milloy & Bubric, 2018;Weiler et al, 2018); (2) tasks (Bargal et al, 2018;Doss et al, 2018;MacDonald & Keir, 2018;Xie et al, 2018); (3) the physical environment (Arsenault-Knudsen et al, 2018;Weiler et al, 2018); and (4) organizational structures (Arsenault-Knudsen et al, 2018;Bargal et al, 2018;Ibrahim Shire, Thomas Jun, & Robinson, 2018;Podtschaske, Salazar, & Rao, 2018). Importantly, diverse areas of study within human factors and ergonomics (perception, cognition, physical ergonomics, organizational ergonomics) are considered within these papers and most papers address more than one area.…”