See article by Sun et al., pages 1153e1157 of this issue.The diagnosis of left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) by means of the electrocardiogram (ECG), when complemented by imaging modalities, is a strong predictor of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. 1 The ECG is commonly used for the diagnosis of LVH because of its wide availability and cost effectiveness. A positive ECG finding can promote further investigations and potential changes in management, whereas a negative finding can be used for reassurance. It is well recognised that the correlation of QRS voltage with anatomical LVH is not a consistent finding and is influenced by multiple confounding factors such as age, sex, race, and ethnicity. 2 Despite research that has led to the development of several ECG criteria for the diagnosis of LVH, the sensitivity and specificity in predicting the presence of anatomically validated LVH is still a concern. The most commonly used ECG criteriadsuch as the Sokolow-Lyon index, Cornell Voltage, and the Gubner and Romhilt-Estes criteriaddeliver a wide range of sensitivity (0% to 68%) and specificity (53% to 100%) 3 . Peguero et al recently described the Peguero-Lo Presti (PLP) criterion for diagnosing LVH from a regular 12-lead ECG in a retrospective single-centre study involving a small American cohort. 4 The described measure is the sum of the deepest S-wave (SD) in any single lead and the S-wave amplitude of lead V4 (SV4). When compared with the Sokolow-Lyon and Cornell voltage criteria, the SD represented the most accurate continuous single linear measurement for the diagnosis of LVH and, when combined with the SV4, had a better diagnostic accuracy. The study concluded that the PLP criterion improved on the Cornell voltage criteria with an increased sensitivity of 65% vs 35%. In this issue of Canadian Journal of Cardiology, Sun et al 5 explore validation of the PLP ECG criterion, compared with the Sokolow-Lyon voltage and Cornell criteria, in a large Chinese population. The study concluded that Cornell voltage had a relatively higher sensitivity and specificity than the PLP criterion in diagnosing echocardiographic LVH.According to the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association/Heart Rhythm Society ECG guidelines, there are at least 36 ECG criteria for LVH. None of them is considered superior to the other, and all have low sensitivity and high specificity. The most commonly used ECG-LVH criteria are listed in Table 1. 4,6-8
Limitations of the ECG-LVH CriteriaThe ECG diagnosis of LVH is quite reliable when prominent QRS voltage is seen in conjunction with other variables such as ST segment changes, left atrial abnormality, widening of the QRS, or leftward axis. However, when the QRS voltage alone is considered, false positive and false negative results are common. This is largely because universal ECG criteria are predicated on fixed QRS voltage, which apply identical voltage cut-offs to the young and elderly, to men and women (Sokolow-Lyon criterion), and to persons with low and high body mass index...