Assessing the ecological status of candidate reference lakes in Ireland using palaeolimnology

Abstract

Summary1. The European Union (EU) Water Framework Directive (WFD) requires that member states establish type-specific reference conditions for all waterbodies, including freshwater lakes. This presents a problem in those locations where human activity has resulted in significant changes to the biological, chemical and physical characteristics of waterbodies. 2. Seventy-six oligotrophic and meso-oligotrophic [0 -19 µ g total phosphorus (TP) L ] lakes thought to be relatively unimpacted by human activity have been nominated as candidate reference lakes (CRL) by the Irish Environmental Protection Agency. This research has used palaeolimnological (lake sediment-based) techniques to test the actual and historical ecological site-specific status of a representative selection of these CRL. Where the temporal record of sedimentation was sufficiently long, the study adopted c. 1850  as the primary baseline date for reference conditions. 3. Short sediment cores were obtained from the deepest parts of 35 CRL, and chronologies were established from profiles of spheroidal carbonaceous particles (SCP). Twenty-two cores of sediment appeared to date back to c. 1850 on the basis of SCP concentrations. Unless the SCP chronologies suggested otherwise, diatom assemblages present in top and bottom samples from the cores were used as proxies of, respectively, present-day and reference conditions. Past lake water pH (DI-pH) and TP concentration (DI-TP) were inferred from the diatom data. Higher resolution sampling (up to five sediment samples per core) was adopted at seven sites where the SCP-based chronology was more robust and for at least one core from each of the most common types of CRL. Sediment chemistry data were determined to identify possible anthropogenic drivers of the observed changes in the diatom assemblages. 4. Ordination and dissimilarity measures identified the main patterns of variation in the diatom data. Eleven of 34 CRL for which diatom data were available showed little or no change in biological status between core top and bottom samples. Core bottom samples in six of these dated back to pre-or c. 1850 and reference (and high ecological) status could therefore be confirmed in these cases. The estimated age of core bottom samples in the remaining five cores was in the period just after c . 1850 to c. 1950  (four cores) or was impossible to determine (one core). Twenty-three (68%) of the CRL sampled showed biologically important deviation from the reference condition, with acidification and nutrient enrichment seemingly the main causes of change. Catchment disturbance, notably peat erosion possibly linked to recent afforestation, also appeared to have been a factor in some cases. 5. Synthesis and applications. This study provides the first systematic examination of changes to water quality in (perceived) pristine lakes over the last c . 150 years for Ireland, and demonstrates the potential of palaeolimnology to support the implementation of the WFD. The results indicate that diatom communities in low alkalinit...

Assessment of ecological status in UK lakes using benthic diatoms

“…Unlike rivers, lakes have the benefit of a sedimentary record that can be used to establish historical conditions directly (e.g., Bennion et al 2004, Bennion and or can be used to assess whether lakes have undergone change in response to pressures, such as eutrophication, and thereby to identify those lakes that might be considered as reference sites (e.g., Leira et al 2006). For the purpose of developing the LTDI, 35, 13, and 7 reference sites were identified for LA, MA and HA lake types, respectively.…”

Using multiple approaches to develop nutrient criteria for lakes in the conterminous USA

“…Other investigators have used paleolimnology to assess reference status. In Ireland, Leira et al (2006) found that 68% of candidate reference lakes showed important deviations from reference condition resulting from acidification and nutrient enrichment. Similar analyses by Bennion et al (2004) in Scotland showed that 19 of 26 lochs had historical increases in total P of .5 mg/L.…”

Monitoring compared with paleolimnology: implications for the definition of reference condition in limed lakes in Sweden

“…Moreover, a critical question is whether the nineteenth century is the most appropriate period to use as a reference point. Several studies have questioned this; especially in areas which have suffered long-term human impact (Renberg et al 1993b;Andersen et al 2004;Leira et al 2006), and the importance of long-term perspectives in defining reference conditions has been stressed by Willis and Birks (2006). Several paleolimnological studies have already demonstrated extensive human impacts in the nineteenth century, through agriculture, mining and forestry activities, as well as from air pollution (Brännvall 2000;Ek 2000;Korsman 1993).…”