Assessing the Credibility and Authenticity of Social Media Content for Applications in Health Communication: Scoping Review

Abstract

Background Nutrition science is currently facing issues regarding the public’s perception of its credibility, with social media (SM) influencers increasingly becoming a key source for nutrition-related information with high engagement rates. Source credibility and, to an extent, authenticity have been widely studied in marketing and communications but have not yet been considered in the context of nutrition or health communication. Thus, an investigation into the factors that impact perceived source and message credibility and authenticity is of interest to inform health communication on SM. Objective This study aims to explore the factors that impact message and source credibility (which includes trustworthiness and expertise) or authenticity judgments on SM platforms to better inform nutrition science SM communication best practices. Methods A total of 6 databases across a variety of disciplines were searched in March 2019. The inclusion criteria were experimental studies, studies focusing on microblogs, studies focusing on healthy adult populations, and studies focusing on either source credibility or authenticity. Exclusion criteria were studies involving participants aged under 18 years and clinical populations, gray literature, blogs, WeChat conversations, web-based reviews, non-English papers, and studies not involving participants’ perceptions. Results Overall, 22 eligible papers were included, giving a total of 25 research studies. Among these studies, Facebook and Twitter were the most common SM platforms investigated. The most effective communication style differed depending on the SM platform. Factors reported to impact credibility included language used online, expertise heuristics, and bandwagon heuristics. No papers were found that assessed authenticity. Conclusions Credibility and authenticity are important concepts studied extensively in the marketing and communications disciplines; however, further research is required in a health context. Instagram is a less-researched platform in comparison with Facebook and Twitter.

Where Do Online Games Fit into the Health Behaviour Ecology of Emerging Adults: A Scoping Review

“… [ 91 ] Celebrities/micro-celebrities Study identified the influence of a mainstream public person (celebrity) or an individual who has gained a large following through social media (microcelebrity) in impacting behaviour. [ 4 , 92 ] Government/health promotion Study identified the influence of health information and health interventions, most commonly issued by government, health promotion or related agencies Media The influence by popular culture through traditional media such as film and television. Advertising Study identified the influence of the advertising of food and drink or the advertising of social norms relating to eating, drinking and activity [ 93 ] Socio-cultural influences Culture Study identifies the influence of behaviour expectations based on belonging to an ethnic or cultural group Social norms Study identifies the influence of behaviour based on societal expectations (not directly related to ethnic groups or gender norms) [ 94 ] Gender Study identified the influence of behaviour based on gender norms Online games and eSports Games and eSports The influence of computer games and organized online games activities and competitions (esports) [ 5 ] …”

Predictors of COVID-19 Preventive Behavior Adoption Intention in Malaysia

“…A study by Lin et al (2020) figured out that people use social media during the COVID-19 outbreak to obtain information related to preventive behavior, virus transmission, and disease symptoms. There is a rising body of social media literature examining health environments, such as public health surveillance, promotion, and communication ( Giustini et al, 2018 ; Jenkins et al, 2020 ). Studies related to the roles of social media on public health during the COVID-19 pandemic have focused on areas such as public attitudes, assessing mental health, and evaluation of prevention education ( Tsao et al, 2021 ).…”

Strategies to Improve Health Communication: Can Health Professionals Be Heroes?

“…We await the application of these techniques to other areas in regard to stemming the proliferation of misinformation. Our previous research has identified many factors that may impact the trustworthiness and authenticity of such posts such as number of followers, message appeal, and authority cues [28]. However, there is a paucity of research on the influence of either NPs or SMIs on perceived trustworthiness and authenticity of SM posts [28].…”

“…Originally, the questionnaire had a broad scope and included questions relating to communication objectives, SM behaviour, and physical activity. However, based on the findings of our scoping review [28] these analyses focus only on the results relating to trustworthiness, authenticity, and message appeals [16,37,38].…”