Assessing Quality Improvement in Health Care: Theory for Practice

Abstract

To review the role of theory as a means to enhance the practice of quality improvement (QI) research and to propose a novel conceptual model focused on the operations of health care. METHODS:Conceptual model, informed by literature review. RESULTS:To optimize learning across QI studies requires the integration of small-scale theories (middle-range theories, theories of change) within the context of larger unifying theories. We propose that health care QI research would benefit from a theory that describes the operations of health care delivery, including the multiplicity of roles that interpersonal interactions play. The broadest constructs of the model are entry into the system, and assessment and management of the patient, with the subordinate operations of access; recognition, assessment, and diagnosis; and medical decision-making (developing a plan), coordination of care, execution of care, referral and reassessment, respectively. Interpersonal aspects of care recognize the patient/ caregiver as a source of information, an individual in a cultural context, a complex human being, and a partner in their care. Impacts to any and all of these roles may impact the quality of care.CONCLUSIONS: Such a theory can promote opportunities for moving the field forward and organizing the planning and interpretation of comparable studies. The articulation of such a theory may simultaneously provide guidance for the QI researcher and an opportunity for refinement and improvement. Pediatrics 2013;131:S110-S119

What roles do middle managers play in implementation of innovative practices?

“…In recent years, changes in the health care environment have led to an increased emphasis on improving quality of care by focusing on safety, efficiency, and value (Kleinman & Dougherty, 2013; Institute of Medicine, 2001). Although there has been a push for changing clinical practice, doing so has proven difficult (Conway & Clancy, 2010; Leape et al, 2009).…”

Pediatrician preferences, local resources, and economic factors influence referral to a subspecialty access clinic

“…The referring PCP is essential to the Access Clinic model as co-manager of the patient. Continuous improvement of the innovative care delivery system requires the PCP perspectives identified in the survey to be integrated with other stakeholder input, patient experiences, health outcomes, and cost effectiveness data (Kleinman and Dougherty, 2013). …”

Outcomes evaluation: Striving for excellence in ambulatory care pharmacy practice

“…9 The method you ultimately use for implementing your quality-improvement plan will depend in part on the culture and structure of your organization. The lean and Six Sigma methods tend to focus on structure and process, and the accomplishment of your goals may require a larger team and implementation at a higher organizational level.…”

“…An additional opinion is that the healthcare quality industry has not identified the highest priorities for measurement, such as patient safety, or has not concentrated on using measures that are of highest value. 9 As one IOM report stated, if banking were like healthcare, the automated teller transaction would take days or longer due to unavailable or misplaced records; if home building were like healthcare, carpenters, electricians, and plumbers each would work off different blueprints with very little coordination. 32 As healthcare providers, we can articulate the problems; the difficulty is in improving at an acceptable pace.…”