Yttrocene derivatives [Cp* 2 Y(MMe 4 )] (Cp* = C 5 Me 5 ; M = Al, Ga) and Cp* 2 Y[Me 3 Al{B(NDippCH) 2 }] (Dipp = C 6 H 3 iPr 2 -2,6) deprotonate benzene at elevated temperatures via the release of methane. The formation of [Cp* 2 Y(Me 2 MPh 2 )] (M = Al, Ga), Cp* 2 Y(MPh 4 ) (M = Al, Ga), Cp* 2 Y[Me 2 AlPh{B(NDippCH) 2 }], and Cp* 2 Y[AlPh 3 {B(NDippCH) 2 }] can be controlled via the temperature applied. The activation temperature and formation of the coordinatively unsaturated "reactive" [Cp* 2 YMe] strongly depend on the coordination strength of the displaceable Lewis acids [AlMe 3 ] 2 , GaMe 3 , and [Me 2 Al{B(NDippCH) 2 }] 2 . Hence, [Cp* 2 Y(AlMe 4 )] requires temperatures above 100 °C to metalate benzene, while Cp* 2 Y[AlMe 3 {B(NDippCH) 2 }] undergoes C−H-bond activation even at ambient temperatures. A kinetic deuterium isotope effect was observed for the reactions in C 6 D 6 solutions. Distinct differences in the stabilities of the bulky Group 13 anions ([Me 2 MPh 2 ] − , [MPh 4 ] − , [Me 3 Al{B(NDippCH) 2 }] − , [Me 2 AlPh{B(NDippCH) 2 }] − , and [AlPh 3 {B(NDippCH) 2 }] − ) are assessed by detailed studies of the coordination chemistry with tetrahydrofuran (THF) and by variable-temperature 1 H NMR spectroscopy. Thus, increased steric bulk or a reduced Lewis acidity of the Group 13 metal center promote temperature-sensitive dissociation of trivalent Group 13 alkyl entities. Consequently, compound Cp* 2 Y[AlPh 3 {B(NDippCH) 2 }] was found to engage in a dissociation equilibrium with [Cp* 2 YPh] and AlPh 2 {B(NDippCH) 2 } in a C 6 D 6 solution at ambient temperature. The reaction of Cp* 2 Y[AlPh 3 {B-(NDippCH) 2 }] with THF results in the concomitant formation of monometallic Cp* 2 YPh(THF) and the solvent-separated ion pair [Cp* 2 Y(THF) 2 ][AlPh 3 {B(NDippCH) 2 }].