Articulating the service concept in professional service firms

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to propose a solution to the challenges of professional service firms (PSF), which are referred to as cat herding, opaque quality and lack of process standardization. These result from misalignment in the mental pictures that managers, employees and customers have of the service. The study demonstrates how the process of articulating a shared service concept reduces these challenges. Design/methodology/approach A narrative methodology is used to analyze the perspectives of old management, new management and employees during organizational change in a PSF – a website design company growing to offer full-service branding. Group narratives are constructed using longitudinal data gathered through interviews and fieldwork, in order to compare the misaligned mental pictures and show the benefits of articulating the service concept. Findings Professional employees view growth and change as threats to their culture and practice, particularly when new management seeks to standardize processes. These threats are revealed to stem from misinterpretations caused by miscommunication of intentions and lack of participation in decision making. Articulating a shared service concept helps to align understanding and return the firm to equilibrium. Research limitations/implications The narrative methodology helps unpack conflicting perspectives, but is open to claims of subjectivity and misrepresentation. To ensure fairness and trustworthiness, informants were invited to review and approve the narratives. Originality/value The study contributes propositions related to the value of articulating a shared service concept as a means of minimizing the challenges of PSFs.

Internal marketing, service quality and perceived customer satisfaction

“…Discrete transactions are shorter-term transactions with a distinct beginning and end. In contrast, relational exchanges are longer, reflecting an ongoing process in which social aspects of the relationship become important (Beltagui et al, 2017;Concha, 2013). Evolving "dominant logic" in relationship marketing theory is moving away from tangibles such as skills and knowledge towards intangibles, such as interactivity, connectivity and ongoing relationships between employees and customers (Madhavaram et al, 2014).…”

Decision‐making and leadership challenges in partner‐based, owner‐managed companies

“…Professional service firms include, but are not limited to, firms in the industries of accounting, architecture, advertising, legal advice, management consulting, and IT-consulting. Professional service firms are characterized by three distinctive features (Beltagui et al, 2017):…”

A codified executive education custom client engagement process

“…In that EE arena, it is important to note that business schools manifest many of the attributes of a classic professional services firm—“high labor content, high customization [of activities], and high customer contact,” as well as providing “knowledge-intensive” services dependent upon “expert talent” (Beltagui et al , 2017, pp. 594–595); these very attributes potentially contribute to “a conflict between managerial control [at the organizational level] and professional autonomy [at the expert talent delivery level]” (Beltagui et al , 2017, p. 607).…”