Aristotle and Autism: Reconsidering a Radical Shift to Virtue Ethics in Engineering

Abstract

Virtue-based approaches to engineering ethics have recently received considerable attention within the field of engineering education. Proponents of virtue ethics in engineering argue that the approach is practically and pedagogically superior to traditional approaches to engineering ethics, including the study of professional codes of ethics and normative theories of behavior. This paper argues that a virtue-based approach, as interpreted in the current literature, is neither practically or pedagogically effective for a significant subpopulation within engineering: engineers with high functioning autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Because the main argument for adopting a character-based approach is that it could be more successfully applied to engineering than traditional rule-based or algorithmic ethical approaches, this oversight is problematic for the proponents of the virtue-based view. Furthermore, without addressing these concerns, the wide adoption of a virtue-based approach to engineering ethics has the potential to isolate individuals with ASD and to devalue their contributions to moral practice. In the end, this paper gestures towards a way of incorporating important insights from virtue ethics in engineering that would be more inclusive of those with ASD.

Factor structure of the Dispositional Hope Scale amongst South Africans: An exploratory structural equation modelling study

“…We therefore see an intertwined hybrid of practical wisdom and the will to achieve success. Practical wisdom is broadly described by Furey (2017) as the use of subjective and contextual resources in response to real life situations and not relying only on contemplative knowledge. This disposition, also known as phronesis, equips a person with an ability to view situations from multiple perspectives and to 'navigate a variety of contextually complex situations' (Furey, 2017, p. 473).…”

Kant, emotion and autism: towards an inclusive approach to character education

“…If, like HF-ASD Mr Darcy, you struggle with your own nature, you are incapable of immunity to your feelings of superiority (or as Austin might call it -conceit), it is difficult to see how you could attain continence. I follow Heidi Furey on this; her account of Aristotle has it that such a constant internal struggle against one's own feelings, would constitute a flaw in one's character (Furey 2017). As such, it isn't that Mr Darcy falls short on his path to virtue compared to someone with the appropriate emotional responses; he is 'on the wrong path altogether' (Furey 2017, 480).…”