Are We Overlooking Harms of BDDE-Cross-Linked Dermal Fillers? A Scoping Review

Abstract

Abstract1,4-Butanediol ether (BDDE) is widely used as a cross-linker for hyaluronic acid in dermal fillers. The purpose of this scoping review was to determine the state of knowledge about the behaviour of cross-linked substances and safety of BDDE application. The rationale behind the review came from the clinical experience of the corresponding author, who noticed adverse reactions after BDDE-linked hyaluronan application. The scoping review was conducted according to PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Out of 399 articles, 52 met the inclusion criteria. Data on study design, sample/population, aims, methodology, outcomes and funding were extracted. Results were charted according to 6 subtopics: rheological properties, hydrogel stability, BDDE toxicity, immunogenicity, tissue interactions and clinical studies. In vitro, cross-linked hydrogels were characterized as effective fillers in terms of viscosity and elasticity; however, previously uncharacterized by-products of the cross-linking reaction were found. Most in vivo studies reported increased dermis regeneration, vascularization and anti-inflammatory cytokine release after implantation of BDDE-cross-linked substances. In clinical studies, BDDE was shown to sensitize subjects to 1,6-hexanediol ether and other substances found in epoxy resin systems. Occupational dermatitis and hypersensitivity reactions were documented. Our review shows that BDDE may have long-term adverse effects, which are overlooked in the safety assessment of fillers. Reviews on BDDE conducted so far have mostly been sponsored by the industry, potentially leading to incomplete reporting of adverse effects. A review of the occurrence of allergic reactions after commercial dermal filler use and analysis of possibly harmful by-products of BDDE hyaluronan degradation are needed.Level of Evidence III This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.