Are there too few women presenting at emergency medicine conferences?

Abstract

Introduction There is a perception that women are under-represented as speakers at emergency medicine (EM) conferences. We aimed to evaluate the ratio of male to female speakers and the proportion of presenting time by gender at major international EM conferences. Methods Conference programmes of the major English-speaking EM conferences occurring from 2014 to 2015 were obtained. The number of presentations, the gender of the speaker and the duration of each presentation were recorded. Results We analysed eight major EM conferences. These included 2382 presentations, of which 29.9% (range 22.5%-40.9%) were given by women. In total, 56 104 min of presentations were analysed, of which 27.6% (range 21%-36.7%) were delivered by women. On average, presentations by women were 95 s shorter than presentations by men (23 vs 21 min 25 s). Conclusions Male speakers exceed female speakers at major EM conferences. The reasons for this imbalance are likely complex and multifactorial and may reflect the gender imbalance within the specialty. BACKGROUND

Gender Disparities in Academic Emergency Medicine: Strategies for the Recruitment, Retention, and Promotion of Women

“…A first step is to provide job‐specific mentorship to senior residents with individualized attention and coaching on CV building, interviewing techniques, and contract negotiation. In addition, improvements in the hiring process such as gender‐blind evaluations and incorporating women in recruitment as well as acknowledging the existing biases could help . Educational interventions targeting gender bias in hiring practices have demonstrated enhanced awareness after program implementation.…”

“…As described above, women are less likely to be promoted to associate and full professors and have leadership positions than men . Gender imbalances in many areas pertinent to promotions, such as authorship, grant funding, speakerships, and participation on editorial boards, have been well documented and need to be addressed …”

Women in EM: pushing our heads above the parapet

“…The excellent thought-provoking article by Sunga and Kass in the EMJ has outlined an intervention aimed at developing the speaking skills of women in EM 1. In their paper, they state that the evidence suggests that only 29.9% speakers at international EM conferences were women 2. It was this along with their own observations of how few women were keynote speakers that gave the idea for this study.…”

Women and Men Were Proportionally Represented Among Speakers at Major National Neurology Conferences in 2017

“…2 In contrast, an analysis of programs from eight international emergency medicine conferences from 2014 to 2015 found that only 29.9% of presentations were given by women. 3 However, the proportion of qualified female emergency medicine specialists in the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, and Australia ranged from 23.5 to 30.0%, suggesting that no relative discrepancy exists. Supporting these findings, a recent large analysis of 181 medical and surgical conferences in the US and Canada found that over the last decade (2007-2017) the mean proportion of female speakers (34.1%) was similar to the mean proportion of active female physicians across all specialties (32.4%) during the same time period.…”