“…This property seems to be in contrast with the hypothesis suggested by Bozzo et al (2008) that SFXTs are magnetars. Moreover, Bozzo et al (2008) suggest that, to get the large dynamic ranges observed in SFXTs, these transients should host neutron stars with long spin periods (of the order of 1000 s or larger), which is not observed in SFXTs, to date: indeed, four SFXTs are X-ray pulsars with much shorter spin periods: IGR J11215-5952 (187 s, Swank et al 2007), AX J1841.0-0536 (4.7 s, Bamba et al 2001), IGR J18483-0311 (21 s, Sguera et al 2007b), IGR J16465-4507 (228 s, Lutovinov et al 2005). The large dynamic range between the quiescence and the maximum luminosity at the peak of the flares can, in any case, be explained already if the supergiant winds are clumpy with density contrasts as large as 10 5 (e.g.…”