Are tailored health education materials always more effective than non-tailored materials?

Abstract

While promising, the evidence in support of tailored health communication has not been overwhelming. One explanation is that tailored materials may be far superior to non-tailored materials in some cases, but only slightly better, no different or less effective in others. In this study, 198 overweight adults were randomly assigned to receive either tailored or non-tailored weight loss materials. Participants' cognitive, affective and behavioral responses to the materials were measured at an immediate and 1 month follow-up. Analyses compared those who received tailored materials to those who received non-tailored materials that were--by chance alone--either a good fit, moderate fit or poor fit, based on the match between behavioral characteristics of the participant and content of the non-tailored materials. Findings showed that good-fitting non-tailored materials performed as well or better than tailored materials for several cognitive, affective and behavioral outcomes. However, moderate- and poor-fitting non-tailored materials were consistently inferior to both approaches. The art and science of creating tailored health communication programs is still evolving. Data from this study suggest present approaches to tailoring are more effective than non-tailored materials in most, but not all cases. Specific recommendations are made describing ways to refine tailoring methods to maximize the effectiveness of this approach.

Share Videos, Not Pills: A Content Analysis of Prescription Drug Videos on YouTube for Presence of Behavior Change Theory

“…This result coincided with the findings of Doshi et al (2003), who concluded that online physical activity websites provided adequate knowledge-based information and guidelines, but incorporated very few theory-based strategies [14]. This and other research has concluded that there is a need for websites to improve interaction and to better tailor assistance to the needs of users, since these methods are expected to have greater impact on behavior change [20]. This is consistent with the traditional approach of health education that largely focuses on the dissemination of health information.…”

Tailoring the Mode of Information Presentation: Effects on Younger and Older Adults' Attention and Recall of Online Information

“…In this study, we refer to "mode tailoring" as adjusting information to match individual preferences for presentation modality, using verbal (text), visual (static illustrations), and/or audiovisual (videos) information (Mayer, 2001). Mode tailoring is important, as the way in which message content is processed and remembered very much depends on how this information is being delivered (Kreuter, Oswald, Bull, & Clark, 2000;Ritterband, Thorndike, Cox, Kovatchev, & Gonder-Frederick, 2009). The ability to correctly remember and reproduce information is often referred to as recall of information (Jansen et al, 2008;Lang, 2000).…”

Baby, Be Safe: the effect of tailored communications for pediatric injury prevention provided in a primary care setting

“…However, it is more typically the case that a clinical population varies considerably in terms of behavior, motivation, learning needs, and other characteristics. In such cases, tailored educational materials often prove to be more effective than generic media [38][39][40]. Tailored messages are those that are individually customized and can, for example, address a person's particular diagnostic, motivational, or behavioral characteristics.…”