Are Population and Land Use Changes Perceived as Threats to Sense of Place in the New West? A Multilevel Modeling Approach

Abstract

The Intermountain West's rapid changes in population growth and land use may be welcome to some, but others perceive such changes as threats to sense of place. The objective of this study is to assess whether New West and Old West contextual variables predict how agricultural landowners view threats to agricultural lifestyles and sense of place. We analyze survey data collected from 2,270 agricultural landowners in Colorado and Wyoming utilizing a multilevel regression model (MLM). We posit that this analytical approach is effective for evaluating hierarchal New West or Old West economic configurations that may otherwise be difficult to observe. Our study specifically examines whether population pressures threaten agricultural lifestyles in the amenity‐based New West or in Old West economic regimes with proclivity toward large‐scale agricultural production. Our results show that landowners in farming‐dependent counties and in high‐amenity areas express greater concern than other landowners surveyed about increases in population growth that could threaten an agricultural way of life. Furthermore, we demonstrate that these perceptions relate to whether individuals reside in New West or Old West counties. In summary, some of the contextual variables of New West and Old West economic structures predict whether individuals perceive population growth and land use changes as threats to sense of place.

The American West as a social-ecological region: drivers, dynamics and implications for nested social-ecological systems

“…There are few regions as evocative and symbolically powerful as the American West (hereafter, 'the West'). As the setting to countless cinematic morality tales and home to some of the world's most recognizable dryland and alpine landscapes, the West possesses a strong and enduring regional identity (Keske et al 2017). The West is also diverse, and includes rural ranching communities in grassland ecosystems, high-tech micro-urban centers in Rocky Mountain valley bottoms, extraction-dominated landscapes across the high desert, Tribal nations managing natural resources within and across sovereign borders, myriad outdoor recreation destinations from alpine to riverine, and many other centers of human-environment interactions.…”

Like Oil and Water in the American West: Water Market Access amid Unconventional Oil Production in Colorado

“…As global climate change continues to dynamically alter conditions, inequitable access to water will have increasingly dire consequences for all water users, but especially newer and water‐poor operators. In a state such as Colorado, where amenity‐oriented New West development such as hobby farms and exurban housing, sustainable farming, recreation, and tourism have begun to displace extractive industries, these resource conflicts often create tensions within communities (Keske et al ). Leaving water acquisition to the free market may continue to mean that smaller agricultural operators are increasingly outpriced, and that some industries, though less controversial than UOG production, may involve even higher consumptive uses.…”

Social scientific research on the American West: current debates, novel methods, and new directions

“…They include nonhuman actors that dynamically respond to human influence, often in unexpected ways (Wolch andEmel 1998, Tsing 2015). Social research on community and sense of place in the US West demonstrates how sociodemographic changes manifest in struggles over belonging (Larsen et al 2007, Shumway and Jackson 2008, Keske et al 2017. Yet it is much more than the what of sociodemographic change-it is how these changes occur and why.…”