‘Are decisions about discharge of elderly hospital patients mainly about freeing blocked beds?’ A qualitative observational study

Abstract

ObjectiveTo explore the interactions concerning the frail and elderly patients having to do with discharge from acute hospital wards and their participation in medical decision-making. The views of the patients and the medical staff were both investigated.DesignA qualitative observational and interview study using the grounded theory.Setting and participantsThe setting was three hospitals in rural and urban areas of two counties in Sweden of which one was a teaching hospital. The data comprised observations, healthcare staff interviews and patient interviews. The selected patients were all about to be informed that they were going to be discharged.ResultsThe patients were seldom invited to participate in the decision-making regarding discharge. Generally, most communications regarding discharge were between the doctor and the nurse, after which the patient was simply informed about the decision. It was observed that the discharge information was often given in an indirect way as if other, albeit absent, people were responsible for the decision. Interviews with the healthcare staff revealed their preoccupation with the need to free up beds: ‘thinking about discharge planning all the time’ was the core category. This focus not only failed to fulfil the complex needs of elderly patients, it also generated feelings of frustration and guilt in the staff, and made the patients feel unwelcome.ConclusionsFrail elderly patients often did not participate in the medical decision-making regarding their discharge from hospital. The staff was highly focused on patients getting rapidly discharged, which made it difficult to fulfil the complex needs of these patients.

Traumatic brain injury: Patient experience and satisfaction with discharge from trauma hospital

“…This is probably explained by short hospital stays, where many patients are discharged the day following admission. The low rate of documented planning and involvement of patients in this study may support the description of pressure on acute hospital beds described in the literature (36,37). Regarding the content of the discharge summary, the only factor in favour of patients in the admission stratum was more frequently described follow-ups, reflecting that these patients were discharged directly home, and referred to general practitioners and/or outpatient treatment, where discharge summary is used as a physician referral.…”

Impact and experiences of delayed discharge: A mixed‐studies systematic review

“…Due to a lack of movement and loss of independence, patients expressed concern about deterioration in their general health while in hospital and an increased risk of bed sores . Patients also reported that pressure to discharge them due to bed shortages meant that they had not recovered sufficiently prior to discharge and that their needs had not been addressed effectively . In some cases, this led to avoidable readmissions to hospital …”

“…Discharge delays caused stress for staff for several reasons: they lengthened waiting lists (which the staff had responsibility to reduce) and created pressure for some patients to be discharged home, which in turn created frustration and guilt among staff who felt patients were being pressured to leave hospital . The strong management focus on reducing delayed discharges made staff feel “under the cosh” and adversely affected interprofessional relationships.…”

How does the healthcare system affect medication self‐management among older adults with multimorbidity?

“…This study described a patient group with complex needs. Limited research on physicians' experiences in treating this population reveals that they find them extremely difficult to treat and time‐consuming, and that these patients make the physician unsure of their competence to the extent that the physician consciously avoids responsibility for them . Participants in this study witnessed this and described the problems from their perspective.…”