Aragonite bias exhibits systematic spatial variation in the Late Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, North America

Abstract

Preferential dissolution of the biogenic carbonate polymorph aragonite promotes preservational bias in shelly marine faunas. While field studies have documented the impact of preferential aragonite dissolution on fossil molluscan diversity, its impact on regional and global biodiversity metrics is debated. Epicontinental seas are especially prone to conditions that both promote and inhibit preferential dissolution, which may result in spatially extensive zones with variable preservation. Here we present a multifaceted evaluation of aragonite dissolution within the Late Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway of North America. Occurrence data of mollusks from two time intervals (Cenomanian/Turonian boundary, early Campanian) are plotted on new high-resolution paleogeographies to assess aragonite preservation within the seaway. Fossil occurrences, diversity estimates, and sampling probabilities for calcitic and aragonitic fauna were compared in zones defined by depth and distance from the seaway margins. Apparent range sizes, which could be influenced by differential preservation potential of aragonite between separate localities, were also compared. Our results are consistent with exacerbated aragonite dissolution within specific depth zones for both time slices, with aragonitic bivalves additionally showing a statistically significant decrease in range size compared with calcitic fauna within carbonate-dominated Cenomanian–Turonian strata. However, we are unable to conclusively show that aragonite dissolution impacted diversity estimates. Therefore, while aragonite dissolution is likely to have affected the preservation of fauna in specific localities, time averaging and instantaneous preservation events preserve regional biodiversity. Our results suggest that the spatial expression of taphonomic biases should be an important consideration for paleontologists working on paleobiogeographic problems.

Formation binning: a new method for increased temporal resolution in regional studies, applied to the Late Cretaceous dinosaur fossil record of North America

“…2018; Brocklehurst & Fröbisch 2018; Dean et al . 2019). The tests that we applied to faunal endemicity in the WIB could be easily applied to other taxonomic groups and geographical regions through time to ensure that reported palaeobiogeographical signals are based on appropriate and significant fossil and geological evidence.…”

Spatial sampling heterogeneity limits the detectability of deep time latitudinal biodiversity gradients

“…However, it is also recognized that spatial bias in sampling (e.g. preferential sampling in western Europe and North America) also skews observed palaeobiogeographic patterns [ 3 – 9 , 11 , 35 , 36 ]. Although sampling-standardization approaches have been implemented between palaeolatitudinal bins in some studies (e.g.…”

Radiaxial fibrous calcite forms via early marine‐diagenetic alteration of micritic magnesium calcite

“…The preservation of aragonitic grains and higher Mn and Fe concentrations in Holocene hardground carbonate is relevant in this context. Suboxic to even anoxic porewater settings will enhance aragonite preservation and Fe and Mn enrichment (Jordan et al ., 2015; Dean et al ., 2019).…”