Approaching trust and control in parental relationships with educational institutions

Abstract

Trust is a crucial factor in parent-teacher relationships. However, research on this subject to date has largely concentrated on a narrow range of theoretical perspectives and empirical methods. Most studies collect, analyze, and aggregate quantitative data on trust from a psychological or sociological perspective. The present paper starts by reflecting on previous research in brief and discussing its limitations with regard to a selected case: parents' relationships with educational institutions. On this basis, the paper aims to contribute to the scientific exploration of trust as a holistic phenomenon that encompasses explicit as well as implicit dimensions. In this context, we argue for a broader range of theoretical and empirical methods in research on the phenomenon of trust and its apparently tight entanglement with control in education settings. To this end, we focus on the one hand on the five distinctive facets of trust introduced by Tschannen- Moran and Hoy (2001): benevolence, reliability, competence, honesty, and openness. On the other hand, we refer to Möllering's understanding of trust and control as a duality (2005) where trust and control can go hand-in-hand instead of being understood as inherently conflicting phenomena. Because of this assumed duality, efforts to explain the relationship between trust and control need to be able to account for the complex interplay between the two on different levels of interactions between parents and schools. To demonstrate this point, this paper presents three studies using different methodological approaches: study 1 analyzes relationships between parents and educators in childcare centers, focusing on the collective relevance accorded to trust by educators. Applying the qualitative, reconstructive documentary method to the analysis of group discussions among educators and video-recorded parent-educator meetings, the study places particular emphasis on reconstructing the implicit knowledge underlying educators' implicit orientations toward parents. Its result show that, in contrast to the common rhetoric of partnership between childcare centers and parents, educators perceive and enact their relationships with parents in very different ways. Study 2 aims to shed light on how trust is shaped differently in various settings of interactions between parents and schools. To this end, a survey is being conducted using a vignette design which provides descriptions of eight forms of parent-school interactions followed by a number of questions corresponding to each of the five facets of trust. The study, which is still in its pilot phase, will thus provide insight about which facets of trust are triggered by the different forms of interaction and, consequently, how the relationship between trust and control is affected by these interactions. Similarly to study 1, study 3 uses a qualitative approach to the analysis of trust. In contrast to study 1, however, the focus of the episodic interviews lies in exploring different elements that shape parental perceptions of te...

Eroding Trust in Teacher Professionalism: An Ethnomethodological Analysis of Radio Interviews with Czech Experts on Education

“…Trust is a complex issue, as documented by philosophical, psychological, as well as sociological studies on the issue which adopt various theoretical perspectives. A useful starting point for our study is offered in the special issue of Studia paedagogica focusing on trust (and control) in education, especially in the text by Schweizer et al (2017), where trust is conceived as a holistic phenomenon that encompasses explicit as well as implicit dimensions. Trust stands as a base in human interactions of all kinds, i.e., trust in individuals, organisations and complex systems.…”

Targeting parent trust to enhance engagement in a school–home communication system: A double-blind experiment of a parental wise feedback intervention.

“…Second, we were unable to collect demographic information on parents due to the privacy law as placed by FERPA, and inferred parental demographic information based on available student data. For example, parental race and ethnicity (Froiland & Davison, 2014), highest achieved education (Schweizer, Niedlich, Adamczyk, & Bormann, 2017), and family structure (Froiland & Davison, 2014) have been demonstrated to play a role in the level of parental trust and satisfaction with teacher interactions. Future studies should then explicitly collect demographic information on parents enrolled in the study.…”

Investigating parents' degrees of trust and communication towards teachers in Indonesian kindergartens

“…For example, Yulianti et al (2018) found that Indonesian parents showed a higher level of communication with school when mothers have a higher education level. Another study by Schweizer et al (2017) revealed that parents with higher educational backgrounds show greater eagerness to personally ensure their children's academic success. Conversely, parents with lower education levels trust teachers more.…”