Approach or Avoid? Exploring Overall Justice and the Differential Effects of Positive and Negative Emotions

Abstract

As empirical research exploring the relationship between justice and emotion has accumulated, there have been key questions that have remained unanswered and theoretical inconsistencies that have emerged. In this article, the authors address several of these gaps, including whether overall justice relates to both positive and negative emotions and whether both sets of emotions mediate the relationship between overall justice and behavioral outcomes. They also reconcile theoretical inconsistencies related to the differential effects of positive and negative emotions on behavioral outcomes (i.e., performance, withdrawal, and helping). Across two field studies (Study 1 is a cross-sectional study with multirater data, N = 136; Study 2 is a longitudinal study, N = 451), positive emotions consistently mediated the relationship between overall justice and approach-related behaviors (i.e., performance and helping), whereas negative emotions consistently mediated the relationship between overall justice and avoidance-related behaviors (i.e., withdrawal). Mixed results were found for negative emotions and approach-related behaviors (i.e., performance and helping), which indicated the importance of considering context, time, and target of the behavior. The authors discuss the theoretical implications for the asymmetric and broaden-and-build theories of emotion as well as the importance of simultaneously examining both positive and negative emotions.

Assessing Emotions Related to Privacy and Trust in Personalized Services

“…Pappas et al [20], while investigating the effects of privacy and enjoyment when using personalized services, they do not investigate any negative emotions. Positive and negative emotions should be studied together as they may have different effects on customers' behavior [34].…”

Shiny happy people buying: the role of emotions on personalized e-shopping

“…Positive and negative feelings may occur simultaneously in customers. It is important to differentiate positive and negative emotions and study them together at the same time, since they can have different consequences and effects on behavioral intentions (Barclay and Kiefer 2012).…”

Building productive relationships with young people with SEBD in transition: the role of identity

“…It may be that the positive emotions an individual experiences when they feel verified are the key to them being able to adjust to identity-challenging situations. Barclay and Kiefer (2014) claim that positive emotions increase energy levels and performance, and result in adaptive behaviours and constructive approaches to organisational change. Whether the energy contained in the reservoir is defined as self-esteem, or is simply the result of positive emotions experienced as a by-product of verification, it does help to explain variation in young people's capacity to cope with change and make the transition out of compulsory education.…”