Applying the Haddon matrix conceptual model to guide motor vehicle crash injury research and prevention in Botswana

Abstract

Introduction Little literature addresses the burden of injury in Botswana, including trauma from motor-vehicle crashes (MVCs). In response, the University of Botswana and the Botswana Ministry of Health and Wellness are collaborating with the University of Pennsylvania to enhance injury and trauma research capacity in Botswana. Here we describe this training program and a research exercise to identify opportunities to prevent, through future research and countermeasures, MVCs specifically in Botswana. Methods We initiated a mixed-methods study during a training module during the first two years of the program. The module introduced the Haddon matrix as a conceptual framework, and asked trainees to identify host, vector, and physical/social environment risk factors for MVCs that, if targeted, may lead to primary, secondary, or tertiary prevention. We conducted 10 photovoice elicitation interviews; results were thematically analyzed to further elucidate the context of MVCs in Botswana and potential countermeasures. Results Our process identified a range of ideas as barriers or facilitators to MVC prevention. The most commonly cited barriers were animals on the road, drunk or reckless driving, poor road quality, lack of road signs/traffic signals to orient drivers, and poor visibility (e.g., no street lighting; poor lighting on vehicles). Regarding primary prevention, participants identified features prior to the crash, across all matrix levels, as influencers of crashes in Botswana. Among these, several human factors (i.e., over-speeding; drunk driving) and environmental factors (i.e., livestock on road) were commonly mentioned as contributors to MVCs, as were cattle gates and traffic calming measures for prevention. Conclusion Results of the Haddon matrix exercise proved useful for training burgeoning Batswana researchers to think conceptually about the occurrence of MVCs in Botswana and think creatively about targeting countermeasures for prevention. The exercise resulted in potential research questions for the trainees to pursue in mentored research of their own.

Haddon’s matrix for spectrum of road-related major injuries in rural adolescents: a case series analysis

“…16,17 Studies outside India have also reported traffic rule violations to be the major cause of road accidents, along with environmental factors like poor street lighting and lack of road signs. [18][19][20][21] These studies emphasize the importance of enforcing traffic regulations, and conducting behavior change education regarding traffic safety rules and their adherence.…”

Risk assessment based on fault tree analysis and analytic hierarchy process in rural areas of Thailand

“…The data collection instrument used in this study was derived from the Haddon Matrix, a highly acknowledged and influential framework in injury prevention. The matrix, developed by William Haddon in 1970, 15 analyses a range of factors related to individual characteristics, features of the vector or agent, and environmental variables before, during, and after an injury or fatality. Hence, the risk assessment form successfully identifies three distinct elements.…”

Risk factors associated with quadbike crashes: a systematic review

“…Intrinsic risk factors were inherent, personal factors attributed to driver characteristics and riding behaviors. They formed the agentbased risk factors according to the Haddon matrix [33,34]. The intrinsic factors (gender, age) were differentiated from the modifiable risk factors (e.g., helmet use).…”