Applying an extended theoretical framework for data collection mode to health services research

Abstract

BackgroundOver the last 30 years options for collecting self-reported data in health surveys and questionnaires have increased with technological advances. However, mode of data collection such as face-to-face interview or telephone interview can affect how individuals respond to questionnaires. This paper adapts a framework for understanding mode effects on response quality and applies it to a health research context.DiscussionData collection modes are distinguished by key features (whether the survey is self- or interviewer-administered, whether or not it is conducted by telephone, whether or not it is computerised, whether it is presented visually or aurally). Psychological appraisal of the survey request will initially entail factors such as the cognitive burden upon the respondent as well as more general considerations about participation. Subsequent psychological response processes will further determine how features of the data collection mode impact upon the quality of response provided. Additional antecedent factors which may further interact with the response generation process are also discussed. These include features of the construct being measured such as sensitivity, and of the respondent themselves (e.g. their socio-demographic characteristics). How features of this framework relate to health research is illustrated by example.SummaryMode features can affect response quality. Much existing evidence has a broad social sciences research base but is of importance to health research. Approaches to managing mode feature effects are discussed. Greater consideration must be given to how features of different data collection approaches affect response from participants in studies. Study reports should better clarify such features rather than rely upon global descriptions of data collection mode.

An Analysis of Response Rate and Economic Costs Between Mail and Web-Based Surveys Among Practicing Dentists: A Randomized Trial

“…We did not ask a specific question about response preference on the questionnaire but we can speculate that dentists may have found it more convenient to complete and mail the survey rather than logging onto the Internet. This is consistent with Social Exchange Theory which postulates that the probability of action being completed is dependent upon an individual's perception of the reward gained [4]. That is, the reward to the dentists for the ''extra step'' of connecting online to complete the survey was low.…”

“…The FTC is derived from a questionnaire created by the National Dental Tobacco Free Steering Committee. The survey instrument inquires about [1] Ask, Advise, Assess, Assist, and Arrange behaviors, [2] availability of patient education materials, [3] barriers to the incorporation of tobacco cessation activities, [4] confidence in assisting patients, [5] the amount and type of training received, and [6] willingness to participate in further training.…”

“…Evolutions in this area have lead to the development of computer-assisted personal interview (CAPI), web-delivered (Internet) surveys and interactive voice response (IVR) surveys [4]. Web-based surveys are viewed as potential viable alternatives to mail or telephone surveys.…”

Screening for religious/spiritual struggle in blood and marrow transplant patients

“…This may be due to the fact that the social workers’ interviews included a general inquiry about R/S but no specific probe for R/S struggle or no language to name it. Patients may also be uncomfortable disclosing R/S struggle in interviews but less inhibited when answering questions about it on a computer [39]. Researchers have found such preferences for computerized assessment, particularly when the questionnaire items address culturally sensitive topics, such as substance abuse [40] or sexual practices [41].…”

Preparatory study for the revaluation of the EQ-5D tariff: methodology report

“…However, it has also been established that individuals may answer face-to-face surveys in a socially desirable way, particularly when answering questions about sensitive issues such as mental health. 59 This may vary according to whether responses were public or anonymous. 60 In the CAPI sample there may be a discrepancy between actual health and reported health status because of the presence of the interviewer.…”