Applying a system dynamics modelling approach to explore policy options for improving neonatal health in Uganda

Abstract

BackgroundThe most recent reports on global trends in neonatal mortality continue to show alarmingly slow progress on improvements in neonatal mortality rates, with sub-Saharan Africa still lagging behind. This emphasised the urgent need to innovatively employ alternative solutions that take into account the intricate complexities of neonatal health and the health systems in which the various strategies operate.MethodsIn our first paper, we empirically explored the causes of the stagnating neonatal mortality in Uganda using a dynamic synthesis methodology (DSM) approach. In this paper, we completed the last three stages of DSM, which involved the development of a quantitative (simulation) model, using STELLA modelling software. We used statistical data to populate the model. Through brainstorming sessions with stakeholders, iterations to test and validate the model were undertaken. The different strategies and policy interventions that could possibly lower neonatal mortality rates were tested using what-if analysis. Sensitivity analysis was used to determine the strategies that could have a great impact on neonatal mortality.ResultsWe developed a neonatal health simulation model (NEOSIM) to explore potential interventions that could possibly improve neonatal health within a health system context. The model has four sectors, namely population, demand for services, health of the mothers and choices of clinical care. It tests the effects of various interventions validated by a number of Ugandan health practitioners, including health education campaigns, free delivery kits, motorcycle coupons, kangaroo mother care, improving neonatal resuscitation and labour management skills, and interventions to improve the mothers health, i.e. targeting malaria, anaemia and tetanus. Among the tested interventions, the package with the highest impact on reducing neonatal mortality rates was a combination of the free delivery kits in a setting where delivery services were free and motorcycle coupons to take women to hospital during emergencies.ConclusionsThis study presents a System Dynamics model with a broad and integrated view of the neonatal health system facilitating a deeper understanding of its current state and constraints and how these can be mitigated. A tool with a user friendly interface presents the dynamic nature of the model using ‘what-if’ scenarios, thus enabling health practitioners to discuss the consequences or effects of various decisions. Key findings of the research show that proposed interventions and their impact can be tested through simulation experiments thereby generating policies and interventions with the highest impact for improved healthcare service delivery.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12961-016-0101-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Trajectories of functional ability over the life course: a conceptual model of the interaction of stressor‐induced functional loss and resilience

“…System dynamics modeling captures complexity by focusing on the causal relationships and dynamic feedback mechanisms between different parts of the system (Sterman, 2001). The system dynamics approach has been used to examine health service delivery (Levin and Roberts, 1976;Semwanga et al, 2016); health care quality improvement (Cavana et al, 1999;Hirsch and Immediato, 1999;Wolstenholme et al, 2007); patient flow and waiting time (Wolstenholme, 1999;Lane and Husemann, 2008;Vanderby and Carter, 2010); health human resources (Ishikawa et al, 2013;Ansah et al, 2015); long-term care for the elderly (Ansah et al, 2013); global healthcare management (Homer et al, 2000;Chick et al, 2008;Thompson and Tebbens, 2008); mental health (Huz et al, 1997;Smits, 2010); and chronic disease management (Homer et al, 2004(Homer et al, , 2007Siegel et al, 2011). This model is thematically similar to the health services delivery model by Levin and Roberts. The model was developed as follows.…”

Computer Simulation Model for Outpatient Clinics in a Brazilian Large Public Hospital Specialized in Cardiology

“…The paper of Newell and Siri (2016) explores the potential for low-order system dynamics (LOSD) models to contribute towards generating reliable predictions of health-policy outcomes. Semwanga et al (2016) applied a system dynamics modeling approach to explore policy options to improve neonatal health in Uganda. They "developed a neonatal health simulation model (NEOSIM) to explore potential interventions that could possibly improve neonatal health within a health system context" (p. 1).…”

System dynamics modelling approach to explore the effect of dog demography on rabies vaccination coverage in Africa

“…The influence of demographic processes was assessed using a system dynamics approach. System dynamics is a modelling method that has been used to understand complex environmental [ 40 ] and public health [ 41 – 44 ] issues. System dynamics models consist of stock (level) and flow (rate) variables which represent ordinary differential equations [ 40 ].…”