Antifragility in Climbing: Determining Optimal Stress Loads for Athletic Performance Training

Abstract

In the past decades, much research has examined the negative effects of stressors on the performance of athletes. However, according to evolutionary biology, organisms may exhibit growth under stress, a phenomenon called antifragility. For both coaches and their athletes, a key question is how to design training conditions to help athletes develop the kinds of physical, physiological, and behavioral adaptations underlying antifragility. An answer to this important question requires a better understanding of how individual athletes respond to stress or loads in the context of relevant sports tasks. In order to contribute to such understanding, the present study leverages a theoretical and methodological approach to generate individualized load-response profiles in the context of a climbing task. Climbers (n = 37) were asked to complete different bouldering (climbing) routes with increasing loading (i.e. difficulty). We quantified the behavioral responses of each individual athlete by mathematically combining two measures obtained for each route: (a) maximal performance (i.e. the percentage of the route that was completed) and (b) number of attempts required to achieve maximal performance. We mapped this composite response variable as a function of route difficulty. This procedure resulted in load-response curves that captured each athlete's adaptability to stress, termed phenotypic plasticity (PP), specifically operationalized as the area under the generated curves. The results indicate individual load-response profiles (and by extension PP) for athletes who perform at similar maximum levels. We discuss how these profiles might be used by coaches to systematically select stress loads that may be ideally featured in performance training.

Less Can Be More: The Hormesis Theory of Stress Adaptation in the Global Biosphere and Its Implications

“…Regular exercise can induce immuno-neuroendocrine stabilization in persons with deregulated inflammatory and stress feedback by reducing the presence of stress hormones and inflammatory cytokines. Nevertheless, biomedical side effects of exercise need to be considered [ 149 ]. According to evolutionary biology, organisms may exhibit growth under stress, a phenomenon that is designated as antifragility.…”

“…A recent review discusses how to determine optimal stress loads for antifragility in climbing. It includes individualized load-response profiles [ 149 ].…”

How does motor performance change with increasing stress doses? A tutorial on dose-response profiles applied to crew rowing

“…Researchers have long been interested in the impact of stressors on human behavior in general and human motor performance in particular. A stressor reflects a stimulus in the environment that fosters an adaptation process by an organism exposed to it [1][2][3] . Different models have been developed to explain the dynamic changes in human motor performance in response to stressors 4,5 .…”

Preparing medical first responders for crises: a systematic literature review of disaster training programs and their effectiveness

“…Effective training involves a systematic and goaloriented execution of exercises for the acquisition or increase of specific competences and skills [11]. The general idea of training is to challenge the current level of performance (e.g., higher intensity, higher difficulty, new content) without being too overwhelming, so that the trainee can adapt and reach a higher performance level [11][12][13][14][15]. However, training resources, including time, budget, and facilities, are usually limited.…”