Analyzing the effectiveness of vocal features in early telediagnosis of Parkinson's disease

Abstract

The recently proposed Parkinson's Disease (PD) telediagnosis systems based on detecting dysphonia achieve very high classification rates in discriminating healthy subjects from PD patients. However, in these studies the data used to construct the classification model contain the speech recordings of both early and late PD patients with different severities of speech impairments resulting in unrealistic results. In a more realistic scenario, an early telediagnosis system is expected to be used in suspicious cases by healthy subjects or early PD patients with mild speech impairment. In this paper, considering the critical importance of early diagnosis in the treatment of the disease, we evaluate the ability of vocal features in early telediagnosis of Parkinson's Disease (PD) using machine learning techniques with a two-step approach. In the first step, using only patient data, we aim to determine the patient group with relatively greater severity of speech impairments using Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) score as an index of disease progression. For this purpose, we use three supervised and two unsupervised learning techniques. In the second step, we exclude the samples of this group of patients from the dataset, create a new dataset consisting of the samples of PD patients having less severity of speech impairments and healthy subjects, and use three classifiers with various settings to address this binary classification problem. In this classification problem, the highest accuracy of 96.4% and Matthew's Correlation Coefficient of 0.77 is obtained using support vector machines with third-degree polynomial kernel showing that vocal features can be used to build a decision support system for early telediagnosis of PD.

Exploring Automatic Diagnosis of COVID-19 from Crowdsourced Respiratory Sound Data

“…Research has now started to use digital technology to gather bodily sounds (e.g., digital stethoscopes) and run automatic analysis on the data [24], for example for wheeze detection in asthma [18,23]. Researchers have also been piloting the use of human voice to assist early diagnosis of a variety of illnesses: Parkinson's disease correlates with softness of speech (resulting from lack of coordination of the vocal muscles) [6,12], voice frequency with coronary artery disease (hardening of the arteries which may affect voice production) [19], and vocal tone, pitch, rhythm, rate, and volume correlate with invisible illnesses such as post-traumatic stress disorder [5], traumatic brain injury and psychiatric conditions [13]. The use of human-generated audio as a biomarker for various illnesses offers enormous potential for early diagnosis, as well as for affordable solutions which could be rolled out to the masses if embedded in commodity devices.…”

Emerging coronavirus diseases and future perspectives

“…Study with enough evidence suggested that speech signals (such as certain vowel, words and numbers) contain vocal biomarkers that could be great aid to pathologist for the disease diagnosis. Several machine learning algorithms showed superior accuracy in disease prediction including Parkinson, depression, cardio and other diseases [38][39][40]. In the light of finding, it can be hypothesized that whether viral infections contain disease specific vocal biomarkers for disease analysis.…”

An Optimized Brain-Based Algorithm for Classifying Parkinson’s Disease

“…Motor symptoms include muscle stiffness, resting tremor, slow movement, and balance problems [5]. Nowadays, evidence exists that signs of PD can be identified through speech, and the analysis using machine learning techniques may help in the diagnosis [6].…”

“…The new position is defined by Equation (6). The bat algorithm is considered a frequency-tuning algorithm that provides a balanced combination of exploration and exploitation.…”

“…where ∈ {−1, 0, 1} andĀ represents the loudness average of all bats. Then, bats move according to Equations (4)- (6). Equation (4) controls the pace and range of bats movements, where β provides variability to the frequencies and it is randomly generated from an uniform distribution within the interval (0, 1).…”