Analyzing 7000 texts on deep brain stimulation: what do they tell us?

Abstract

The enormous increase in numbers of scientific publications in the last decades requires quantitative methods for obtaining a better understanding of topics and developments in various fields. In this exploratory study, we investigate the emergence, trends, and connections of topics within the whole text corpus of the deep brain stimulation (DBS) literature based on more than 7000 papers (title and abstracts) published between 1991 to 2014 using a network approach. Taking the co-occurrence of basic terms that represent important topics within DBS as starting point, we outline the statistics of interconnections between DBS indications, anatomical targets, positive, and negative effects, as well as methodological, technological, and economic issues. This quantitative approach confirms known trends within the literature (e.g., regarding the emergence of psychiatric indications). The data also reflect an increased discussion about complex issues such as personality connected tightly to the ethical context, as well as an apparent focus on depression as important DBS indication, where the co-occurrence of terms related to negative effects is low both for the indication as well as the related anatomical targets. We also discuss consequences of the analysis from a bioethical perspective, i.e., how such a quantitative analysis could uncover hidden subject matters that have ethical relevance. For example, we find that hardware-related issues in DBS are far more robustly connected to an ethical context compared to impulsivity, concrete side-effects or death/suicide. Our contribution also outlines the methodology of quantitative text analysis that combines statistical approaches with expert knowledge. It thus serves as an example how innovative quantitative tools can be made useful for gaining a better understanding in the field of DBS.

Deep brain stimulation for obsessive-compulsive disorder: Knowledge and concerns among psychiatrists, psychotherapists and patients

“…This could reflects the high interest for the field, which can be seen in the increasing number of publications related to DBS for psychiatric indications. [ 15 ]…”

Deep brain stimulation: current challenges and future directions

“…Analysis of a US database of hospital discharges between 2002 and 2011 showed that more than 30,000 DBS surgeries were performed during that time56. The numbers of publications on DBS have also risen steeply over the same period, with more than 7,000 manuscripts published between 1991 and 2014 (REF 57…”

Understanding patterns of COVID infodemic: A systematic and pragmatic approach to curb fake news

“…Mats and Jorgen, 2011 , Vincent, 2021 , Peivand and Amin, 2020 , Blei David et al, 2003 , Scott et al, 2020 , Casero-Ripolles, 2020 , Matteo et al, 2020 , Clarke Jonathan, 2020 , Cook et al, 2014 , Depoux Anneliese et al, xxxx , Mathias et al, 2017 , Simeng et al, 2019 , Matthew and Ines, 2017 , Binxuan and Carley, 2020 , Christian and Markus, 2015 , Li et al, 2021 , LIWC, 2021 , Ben, 2018 , Aythami et al, 2020 , Pennycook et al, 2020 , Gordon et al, 2020b , Pennycook et al, 2020 , Roel, 2000 , Adam and Davey, 2020 , Karishma et al, 2020 , Sievert, 2014 , Lisa et al, 2020 , Marianna, 2020 , Nabiha, 2017 , Wes, 2021 , Wallach Hanna, 2006 , Wu, xxxx , Xue Jia, 2020 , Yuehua et al, 2019 .…”