Analysis of Psychoacoustic and Vibration-Related Parameters to Track the Reasons for Health Complaints after the Introduction of New Tramways

Abstract

Abstract:Background: A change to new tramways in Graz (Austria) led to severe complaints in residential areas. To understand the underlying reasons for these complaints, a systematic measurement campaign was designed. Methods: Six locations in Graz and two locations in a comparably sized city were selected. Parallel indoor recordings of sound and vibrations were conducted from 8:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m. (due to sleep problems) at all locations. Results: Vibration levels remained below the limits of the Austrian standard (Wm-weighting) although variability was observed among sites, tram types and pass-bys. A complex characteristic of the acoustic feature space was found with A-weighting (differences between A-and C-weighting of more than 15 dB were observed). C-weighted background to peak noise ratios clearly distinguished "old" from "new" trams. Psychoacoustic indices indicated a high variability between locations and tram types. Roughness and loudness was higher in "new" versus "old" trams at most locations. "New" trams exhibited high sharpness values and variability, especially at higher speeds-when compared with trams from a control city. Conclusions: Standard indicators of sound and vibration were not sensitive enough to uncover the reasons for the complaints. Only the integrated analysis of the ambient soundscape (high signal-to-noise-ratio), the more noticeable sound (in psychoacoustic terms) and the observed high variance of the immissions provided guidance to implement appropriate technical solutions.

A Taxonomy Proposal for the Assessment of the Changes in Soundscape Resulting from the COVID-19 Lockdown

“…Correlated with the time presence of Traffic L Ceq -L Aeq , difference between Aand C-weighted equivalent continuous sound levels [30][31][32][33][34] Describes the amount of low frequencies [35,36] NA80, number of events above a 80 dBA, or TA80 time above 80 dBA (additional thresholds can be considered) Awakening probability with increasing L Amax The number of high noise level events may affect sleep motility. For aircraft noise, also an effect on annoyance is suggested Calculated from percentiles.…”

Community Response to Multiple Sound Sources: Integrating Acoustic and Contextual Approaches in the Analysis

“…The high truck traffic load of the area suggests the importance of LF assessment. Large parts of this LF-component may have been caught by the question on vibration perception [ 83 , 84 , 85 ].…”

Technical Comparison of Commercially Available Trams and Review of Standardization Frame and Design Principles

“…Due to the low unsprung mass installed on trams and the requirements for life endurance of the rubber under sever conditions of traction and braking which lead to radial stiffness values between 20 and 200 kN/mm, the effectiveness of resilient wheels against ground-borne vibrations is usually very low, especially for vibrations below 80-100 Hz [16,18]. Sometimes old vehicles offer better performance than new vehicles [19], and wheel properties can be one of the reasons.…”